Hidden Secrets of Value

MoneyMan's Avatar
MoneyMan · in Extended Studies
1 comment 294 readers
MoneyMan's Avatar
#1
Extended Learning
Price vs. Value: Why the Difference Matters
Research Paper Beginner 6 Minute Read

Imagine walking into a store and seeing a watch priced at $10,000.

Is it expensive?

Perhaps.

But is it worth $10,000?

That is a completely different question.

One of the most important concepts in economics—and one that is often overlooked—is the distinction between price and value.

Price Is Objective

Price is simply the amount of money exchanged for a good or service.

If a loaf of bread costs $4.00, then its price is $4.00. Everyone sees the same number.

Price is measurable.

Value is not.

Price is determined in the marketplace. Value is determined in the mind of the individual.

Value Is Subjective

Value exists in the mind of the individual.

A bottle of water has little value to someone sitting comfortably at home, but it may be priceless to a hiker stranded in the desert.

The object hasn't changed.

Only the circumstances have.

Likewise, a rare baseball card may be nearly worthless to someone with no interest in sports, while a collector may gladly pay thousands of dollars for it.

Key Concept

Two people can assign completely different values to the exact same item. The item's price may remain constant, but its value depends entirely on the preferences, needs, and circumstances of the individual evaluating it.

Price may be fixed.

Value depends on the individual.

When Something Is Overpriced

People often say an item is "overpriced."

What they really mean is that the asking price exceeds the value they personally receive from owning it.

A luxury handbag may cost $3,000.

One person may see craftsmanship, exclusivity, and quality worth every dollar.

Another may see only leather and stitching.

The price is identical.

The perceived value is not.

When Something Is Overvalued

The term overvalued is commonly used in investing.

It refers to situations where the market price of an asset is believed to exceed its underlying or fundamental value.

During speculative bubbles, investors may bid prices higher because they expect someone else to pay even more in the future—not necessarily because the asset has become more productive or useful.

History is filled with examples:

  • Tulip Mania
  • The Dot-Com Bubble
  • The Housing Bubble
  • Various cryptocurrency booms and busts

Whether an asset is truly overvalued is often debated, but the concept reminds us that market prices and underlying value are not always the same.

Market prices can change in an instant. Underlying value often changes much more slowly.

Why This Matters

Understanding the difference between price and value changes the way you think about money.

Instead of asking:

"How much does it cost?"

You begin asking:

"What am I receiving in return?"

That shift influences nearly every financial decision you make—from everyday purchases to long-term investments.

It also helps explain why markets sometimes appear irrational. Prices move constantly, but value often changes much more slowly.

Learning to distinguish between the two is one of the foundations of sound economic thinking.

Reflection

Before making any purchase or investment, ask yourself whether you are paying for genuine value or simply paying the current market price. Developing the habit of separating the two is one of the most valuable skills in economics and investing.

Learn More

This article pairs well with Alan Hibbard's Hidden Secrets of Money, which explores the nature of money, currency, and value.

As you watch, consider this question:

Does the price of something determine its value—or is value something each individual decides for themselves?

The answer lies at the heart of economics.


YouTube

Last edited by MoneyMan

MoneyMan's Avatar
#2

Alan Hibbard: Growing up, I always felt like the poor kid. I know we weren't poor poor. We were middle class, but rich and poor are relative terms.

It seemed like whenever I went to the other kids' houses in the neighborhood, they had nicer toys, finished basements. They could afford to go on vacations more often than my family. I always felt a little bit insecure about that.

Fortunately, my parents sent me to a private high school, but that only exacerbated the problem. I was surrounded by the richest families in Buffalo, and my insecurities around money only intensified.

So when I went away to college, I started as a mechanical engineer. But after one year, a friend of mine handed me a book — Rich Dad Poor Dad — and I said, "What's this?" He said, "Just read it." And I did.

Hi, I'm Alan Hibbard. That book completely changed my life. I marched down to the guidance counselor's office and said, "I want to change my major from mechanical engineering to finance because I need to learn everything I can about money."

She said, "Really? Are you sure?" I told her, "Yeah, even if I make a lot of money as an engineer, I need to know how to protect it and how to grow it." That was so important to me that I completely changed the direction of my life.

Well, it's been 18 years and I'm still on this path of learning and teaching about money. And over the next six videos, I want to share with you some of the most mind-boggling things I've learned about money and value — and why so many people feel stuck financially.

I also want to share some of the misconceptions that plague even the most seasoned experts in the industry. To my disappointment, I didn't learn many of the things I wanted to learn in school — even studying finance and staying for an MBA. I had to learn most of these things about money and value on my own, and from watching great series like Hidden Secrets of Money by Mike Maloney.

This series is an homage to that series, and I want to share with you some of the things that go even further and are even more foundational.

The problem I had is that the further I went down the money and value rabbit holes, the more I realized it started to feel like a second job. It took all my time watching the news, checking the markets, monitoring my investments to see if they were up or down or if I should make a change. And that's not how I wanted to live my life.

I was looking for a solution that was low-maintenance, where I could set it and forget it. And fortunately, over the last 18 years, I found a solution that works beautifully for me. So now I can spend my time hiking in the woods, spending time with loved ones, reading books, or whatever is interesting to me.

In this series, I want to share everything I've learned about money and value and how you can create a very simple investment strategy for yourself. Or as you'll learn, it's more of a saving strategy than an investment one.

Of course, nothing here is financial advice. This is all part of the financial education that I wish I had when I was in school. And I think everyone should know these foundational concepts.

[Music]

Warren Buffett has famously said, "Price is what you pay. Value is what you get." And he's right. That distinction between price and value is so important. It underpins everything we're going to talk about in this series.

What is intrinsic value? What is extrinsic value? What is a store of value? And more. So let's talk about all those things. But first, let's go somewhere a little more comfortable.

[Transition]

So, why is the distinction between price and value so important? Well, basically everything we do in life is a constant series of trades. And I don't just mean economic trades related to money. I mean everything. We trade our time, our energy, and yes, our money. Price is what we pay in each one of those trades. Value is what we get.

If we're not happy in our lives, then we've probably been making a series of bad trades. So if you want your life to be more valuable and more full of value, you have to pay attention to the prices that you're paying and the values that you're getting.

Let's take a step back. What is value? How do we define it? A lot of people say that value is the certain dollar amount that something has in the store or on the stock exchange. I don't think that's the best definition. It's not really helpful and it doesn't allow for that subjectivity or the opinion of the valuer.

I think the easiest way to think about value is quite simply perceived benefit. That's it. And so if you perceive a certain benefit now versus the way I perceive a certain benefit now, we're going to assign different value judgments. Similarly, what you perceive as a benefit right now might not be a benefit to you later. So your own value judgment can change over time. That's perfectly natural. That's what happens to all of us all the time.

And in fact, this is a beautiful thing. The fact that everybody perceives everything differently at all times is the reason that an economy can exist. If we all assign the same value to everything all the time, no one would make a trade...

[Real Estate Story & Lessons]

Growing up, my dad had several rental properties... [he shares how they actually cost money and caused stress].

I learned that if you're going to own real estate, it's not an automatic way to make money. You have to have a lot of things go your way, and you have to manage those buildings properly.

At one point in high school, my dad took me to one of these rental properties... the neighborhood was rough. I learned an important lesson: location, location, location.

But more broadly, when it comes to investments of any kind, I learned that any investment requires an ongoing expenditure of time, money, and energy. It's not a guarantee that you're going to make a profit...

[Saving vs Investing Section]

Every one of us is saving and investing for the future... Most people think that holding on to US dollars is a form of saving and turning those dollars into any other financial instrument is a form of investing. I would like to challenge that notion.

I would argue that holding a US dollar is already a form of investing — and it's a form of investing that is guaranteed to lose. We know for sure that US dollars, like any fiat currency, are going to lose value over time.

So, if you're holding a large number of dollars, you're choosing to lose value with that portion of your portfolio over time.

Saving is holding a real form of money. In my mind, it's gold, silver, and Bitcoin...

Theme: Emerald Ledger