What Is Money? Debating MMTers

MoneyMan's Avatar
MoneyMan · in Financial News & Discussion
2 comments 89 readers
MoneyMan's Avatar
#1
YouTube

Issuing money is theft. And and a more precise way of putting it is slavery. If I own a form of money, but you have the ability to print more of that money, you're essentially stealing my purchasing power. Until Bitcoin came around, we had no choice.

>> Money. Most of us spend our lives thinking about it, earning it, spending it, worrying about it without ever asking who creates it, who regulates it, and who that system was built to serve. The central bank cannot force money on the population. They don't print money and just drop it by helicopters. It does not work this way.

>> You could tax the rich. Taxing the rich basically reduces their purchasing power. Today, we're asking who controls money.

>> Before we start, tell us where you stand on today's topic. Share your thoughts with us in the comments here on YouTube. I'd like to welcome our guests. Pelvina Chernva is the president of the Levy Economics Institute. Jason Hickle is a professor at the Autonomous University of Barcelona and Sephedin Amus is an economist and author of the Bitcoin Standard. A very warm welcome to the three of you. Thank you for joining us.

>> Thank you.

>> Thank you. Thank you for having us.

>> I'm very excited about this conversation. I am going to learn a lot myself as somebody who is not an economist talking to three very uh accomplished and enlightening people talking about money in our time today. I'm going to ask you a lot of stupid questions. So, please bear with me because I want to learn as much as I can from the three of you and maybe towards the end you all can help me restructure my investment portfolio.

But no pressure, [laughter] can we begin with you? When we talk about money, what does that word actually mean?

>> Money is a medium of exchange. What defines it is that it is a good that is not acquired for its own sake. You don't acquire it to consume it and you don't acquire it as a capital good. You don't acquire it in order to produce other things. The first is a consumption good. The second is a capital good. Money is a different category of good which is acquired purely to be exchanged forward. And this gives it specific properties that are different from other prop from other goods.

But I think the most important fact to understand about money is that it is just another market good and therefore there's a supply, there is a demand and then all of the rules of economics apply to it. And I think a lot of the confusion around money comes from trying to force people into not seeing it as another market good to to then claim that all the rules of supply and demand and the basics of economics do not apply to it.

But anything can be used as a medium of exchange. You can decide to use anything as a medium of exchange as long as you don't consume it, don't use it in production and then exchange it for something else. The question then is what succeeds as a medium of exchange. And I think history shows us there are very clear properties for what makes for a good medium of exchange or what makes for a bad medium of exchange. And in my book, the Bitcoin standard, I argue that the most important property is the increase in the supply of money.

Ultimately, that matters more than anything because a money whose supply increases quickly will be devalued to the point where it cannot function as money. Whereas a money whose supply doesn't increase quickly will continue to maintain the wealth that is stored in it, will continue to function as money, will continue to reward the people who use it. So a fast increase in the supply of money destroys the ability of money to function as money. I think this is an enormously important thing and this explains a lot of the world's problems over the past century where we went from using a money that was limited in its supply growth which is gold to using government money which is much more unlimited in supply growth.

It grows at a much faster rate, creates a lot of uh price inflation, creates a lot of funding power to give more money and power to the government at the expense of the citizens and has financed wars, death, destruction and devastation. All of it because of this very dangerous, very destructive and very murderous idea that government gets to set what money is and government is the arbiter of what money is, which is false and downright criminal, I should say.

>> Well, there's there's got to be a lot here we're going to unpack. Uh, Pavina, what makes money work, function in a society? What is it about the concept of money that allows us to agree on the value of anything? Well, I think it's important to distinguish between money as objects versus money as um units of measure. If I were to say what money is, I would concentrate on its um aspect as a social technology, if you will, that money emerges through the history of time as a way for us to track economic activity, as a way of measuring debts to each other, uh prices, equivalences.

So when you look at how money emerged through time, historical time, uh you would be hardress pressed to find a society that didn't have some kind of standard that was established, usually with the help of some authority. How you and I decide what we owe each other um what our debts are going to be priced in is some kind of um measurement. So the first function I will stress for money would be the unit of account. And you know, it's normal that most people think of money as the object uh that they carry in their wallets, uh the coins that jingle in our pockets, but really um money is just the name for financial instruments, I use.

So think of money as um centimeter, as a foot. Think of money as just the name for for debts. So when you say a dollar, it's not really the uh material manifestation of dollar that is so crucial, but who sets the standard of that we are going to measure our prices and our debts in dollars or in euros. And when you then look through time, you notice that money is not only a social technology, but it also is um part of nation building.

It's part of how um governments manage a polity. Um and so there is a reason why governments are involved in the creation of money. In the modern world, the currency is a public monopoly. Um but that has been a long historical process of nation building um gaining independence from you know foreign powers and acquiring some kind of capacity to manage your economic affairs. So this is what we would call for example monetary sovereignty where um money will be created with the financial institutions that we have built Federal Reserve treasuries.

We issue currencies and um and there is a reason why money is not uh fixed because we need it to be flexible to facilitate growth in economic activity. Now, that word sovereignty is important and we're going to get there because I think a lot of the conversation is about that topic about independence and about sovereignty and about freedom ultimately and who has it and who doesn't have it. But I heard from two the two of you two different slightly different definitions of money, a good and a measurement, which is really interesting.

And Jason, I wonder listening to these two what you agreed with, what you disagreed with.

>> It's interesting. I mean, I suppose probably I'm closer to Pablo's position here. Um, I think one of my worries about uh about Dice position is um I'm not actually sure that we want to think of money as something that should be a uh a permanent store of value in the way that say Bitcoin is that we would speculate on and things like that. Um we can get into that later, but I think that the thing that I would want to add to both of these is simply to say that um that money is not just a neutral thing.

It's it's a highly politically charged thing. Uh it's it's shot through with power imbalances. And I think this is what makes money really interesting, right? the fact that um the money has this incredible power which is the power to effectively mobilize production, right? Like all of us uh you know who work, we receive our wages in uh in a particular currency. Uh and because we need to buy things with that currency, we're incentivized to do more work to get those to get that the currency to uh to buy things we need to do like buy a house or pay for rent or buy food.

So there's there's there's demand for this currency which is what drives us to to seek it. And so whoever is issuing the money uh therefore has power to mobilize our labor right like our labor but also our resources our our collective planet's resources and so there's a crucial question here which is that who who controls the money issuance um and what do they mobilize to do with it um and I think this this is where the rubber hits the road really right so it's not it's not necessarily neutral there's power relations that are at stake and the main thing here is that um technically uh Pavina is absolutely right that that governments or states have a have a monopoly over the issuance of currency.

It's a public monopoly. However, under capitalism, they actually relinquish some of that monopoly power and they franchise it out to commercial banks. And so, commercial banks then under capitalism have the right have the ability to uh to to create money when they uh when they make loans. And so, a huge amount of money in our in our economy is actually created by commercial banks. Now, when now when they create money and make loans, uh what's the purpose for them?

uh they're effectively lending to capitalist enterprises with the objective of making profit. And uh and so as a result, a ma a massive amount of our labor and our collective productive capacities, our factories, our resources, our energy, uh our land is mobilized around uh producing things that will maximize the profits of the capitalist class. And I think this actually leads us to very severe problems. Um for example, we mobilize uh effectively um in a kind of a perverse way, right?

We we have massive production of things like SUVs and fast fashion and private jets because these are highly profitable to capital. But we have chronic underprouction of obviously socially necessary things like affordable housing or renewable energy or agroecology uh things like that because these are much less profitable to capital or not profitable at all. And so I would say the question here really is um is is who controls money in in any given given economy. And specifically the problem we face now I would say um is not money as such but rather uh money in a capitalist economy uh where production is organized around profit maximization not around human needs because I mean think about it we have tons of productive capacity think about the labor that we collectively uh possess um right think about the resources and factories and technologies that we have we could do anything we want

like the social crisis that we have we can we can solve immediately the ecological crisis we have we can solve immediately these are not difficult things to to solve. Uh the main problem is simply that our productive capacities are not mobilized to do those things because they're not profitable and instead they're mobilized to do other things that benefit the profits of uh of those who uh control the means of production, those who own capital. And I think that's the main problem we need to focus on.

>> Safe, I can see you writing things down. I I wonder what you have to say

>> a lot. First [laughter] of all, let me begin by uh saying initially you said u it's money is a unit of account and it always has to be there always has to be an authority that set it and I think this is categorically false. Um gold has existed as money before any single government that exists today had existed. Gold was money and gold continued to be money after all of the world's governments have gone out of business and it continued.

So the Roman Empire collapsed but the gold continued. Gold continued to be as money. So the emergence of gold as money predates the emergence of any state. We have records of people using gold as money before any states existed. And even more importantly to debunk this claim is the clear idea that within societies say the government can impose a specific monetary standard. This silver coin or gold coin or whatever it is. But inter societies between societies there is no single authority that decides.

And yet trade happens. So how does trade happen between strangers who don't live under the same rules under the same authority? The answer is money that exists outside of the state and that's what gold is. Gold is money regardless of whether the state allows it to be money or not. Now the second point is um you said essentially that issuing issuing money is a way of mobilizing labor which is an wonderful Orwellianism but it's a very wrong way of putting it.

Issuing money is theft and and a more precise way of putting it is slavery. if I own a form of money, but you have the ability to print more of that money, you're essentially stealing my purchasing power and taking it to you. Now, if I signed up willingly to um if I was stupid enough to sign up for a form of money that is built to allow you to steal from me, then you could say that's not stealing.

That's just me being an idiot. But in our modern world, we have no choice. We Well, until Bitcoin came around, we had no choice. You had to sign up to the government's money. You had to sign up to being stolen. And you had to sign up to being lectured by economists paid by that stolen money to tell you why that stolen money is for your own.

>> Okay, I just ask a clarifying question. Are you talking about inflation when you talk about theft? Is that what you're referring to?

>> Increasing the supply of money. Increasing the supply of money, devaluing the existing devalues the existing

>> through inflation is what you're talking about.

>> Through increasing the supply, anything whose supply increases its value declines. So

>> So this is the idea of governments having the ability to print money and and and circulate that into their economies.

>> Exactly. It's marketed as if it's a way of mobilizing labor as if it is something that is inevitable that it has to happen. And as you said, you know, we need to increase the supply of money. I think this is the most pernicious misunderstanding of money and it's extremely dangerous because you don't actually need to increase the supply of money because money is unique among all goods in that its quantity is irrelevant to its performance of its function.

In other words, having more tables, more water, more apples, more steak is good because that allows us to meet more people's needs for these goods. With money, it's not the case. We don't need a specific quantity of money for money to perform its function because money's function is purchasing power. And purchasing power is something that is psychological that can be stacked into money without increasing the supply. In other words, you could run the entire world economy on a money supply of a billion dollars or a trillion dollars or hundred trillion dollars or $1.

Doesn't matter. You can just divide the dollar down into smaller and smaller units. You don't need to increase the supply because the purchasing power that can be stored into every unit of supply can be increased. So the only function that is served by increasing the supply of money is just redistribution. It's theft. It's theft from the vast majority of people to the government's central banks. [snorts] And let's face it, the economists that get paid from the inflation to justify this, but [laughter] that's not something.

>> Well, I mean, listen, I I have two I I have two against one, so I got to [laughter] swing.

>> There's actually going to be a lot of agreement between the three of you. I'm I'm certain of it, but I want to stop on this on this point. And Pavina, um, we hear a lot about supply and demand in the way that our economists talk, the way that our government officials talk. What does that actually mean and how does that change the value of money that I have in my bank account?

>> The Bitcoin Standard podcast is sponsored by Crowd Health. Crowd Health is the Bitcoiner's answer to fiat health insurance. If you listen to the show, you've probably heard me rail against the problems of modern healthcare and health insurance. Crowd Health is not insurance. It negotiates with healthcare providers on your behalf and gets you much better rates by offering to pay them cash upfront without having to go through the expensive bureaucracy of modern healthcare insurance. It disintermediates large insurance companies who have the wrong incentives and are constantly raising costs.

I've known Crowd Health CEO Andy Shunover for years now and I've spent quite a bit of time grilling Andy on their model. I've hosted him twice on this podcast and asked him about it and you can listen to those episodes. I think it's a great way to bypass some of the many failures of the modern health care system. If you want to understand how Crowdalth works, go to joincrowalth.com/webinar and sign up for the next live webinar and ask Andy your questions directly.

And when you're ready to join, go to joincrowalth.com and use code safe, that's sif, to get your first three months for $99 a month. Look, it's not the value of money is not about the supply and demand, but what uh it buys. Um let's just go back and just kind of systematize our categories first. Um the very first forms of money that were invented, ancient Mesopotamia, clay tablets, not precious gold, not precious metal. Throughout most of the history of time, money has not been precious.

clay tablets were little ledgers where they notify what you're entitled to two goats, a bushel of wheat. Um, the Mesopotamian palaces organize their production by basically tracking the equivalences of these commodities and money is connected with the origins of writing, the origins of accounting. It was a technology to track economic activity, not to usurp. There are distributional effects. I think I agree with this that as a society we choose who produce, who consumes, where that goes. And when I say governments, I don't mean nation states.

I talk about some kind of governing authority. It could be your priest. It could be the temple that basically figures out, you know, how many chickens get sacrificed, right? And we track, money was created to track that production of the debts, more specifically the debts. What do I owe you? Um, and in the modern world, money is actually debt. It's not a thing that we just print away. While there is printing of currency, that is really not the essence and the heart of money.

Money is debt. Anyone can create money. The point is to get it accepted. I'm quoting an economist Hyman Minsky. The point is to get it accepted. I can issue you an IOU. Will you accept my IU? I promise to pay you something. What will you accept? A cup of sugar or a dollar or a brick of gold? What would you take? And I would venture to say that you would take that which is most acceptable elsewhere in the economy which is what is the final means of payment and that tends to be in the modern world currencies and we can go through the history.

I think Jason is right that money takes a completely new form under capitalism because it becomes a singular obsession right it becomes it so is removed from the basis of economic activity. It looks like it's lubricating our transactions but it's really um it is created in the act of creating credit and that has been throughout time that money is an IOU um and there are private IUs and you can denominate them in bitcoins and you can denominate them in currency uh various currencies which is the most acceptable and it has to do with the arbiter with the um in the modern world the nation state that sets the unit of account the ones that taxes in that unit of account and thus compels the rest of society to transact and denominate our transactions in that ultimate um uh unit clearing.

So I agree taxation has distributive capacities right this the state taxes us but not because it needs its own currency but it because it needs resources to provision for whatever we can conceive as the public purpose and you may say it's for military exploits and you can say for public investment but there is an a crucial function that the state functions to potentially provision for the for the society that it it governs. Can you explain this idea of debt and and credit and and IUS?

What does that mean?

>> Yeah, I mean uh you know uh IOU means that uh there's an issuer and uh that would be the liability of the issuer and then there's going to be somebody who accepts it. So like I said, if I um issue a mortgage, right? That is your debt. As a banker, that is my asset, right? You could think of this as a form of money. If I issue um a um a a bank check to you, I'm a banker and I issue a deposit that is your asset but that is my liability.

The that piece of paper that you carry that bank check is what we call bank money. The bank can create add infinitum. It can create as many bank checks as possible. You can use that check to pay for your transactions but and you accept it because at bottom you are guaranteed that that will clear at par uh through the banking system by the banks exchanging reserves and those are the exclusive prerogative of the state. So the state is liable to um issue that which settles all transactions and it is also liable to accept it in payments to the state.

So you see um the the thing about money is that it has to be redeemable right it's not an object I think that's where the difference is the way I see money is that it is a social technology that is issued by you know creating um issuing an IOU or accepting a means of payment it's not just an object that we exchange uh with each other and this is I think a category era um only economists tell the story of barter no other scientists will talk about societies bartering with each other and one day they wake up and they say, "Aha, we need something to help us with barter transactions.

We need something that has inherent, you know, value, hence precious metals." Because uh first the archaeological evidence does not show any society that has existed um with barter but without money and it doesn't have we don't have any evidence of money originating just from pure barter transactions. money was already was already there. And so, um, I think we need to really move away from this notion that somehow we're transacting with something that has inherent value, precious metal value, and to start thinking about why societies issues IUs and credits to basically facilitate economic transactions.

>> Safe, I feel like you are going to disagree with Pavina.

>> Yes. First of all, uh clay uh was used as money and it wasn't used anymore because it's not scarce and it was used as a ledger, not so much the clay itself, but it failed as money because it is very easy to produce. And if you look at the history of money, you find the exact opposite. The only things that have ever worked as money have only worked as money because there was some because they were the hardest liquid goods to produce.

So whether it was seashells, they'd use the rare seaells in West Africa, they used the glass beads because they didn't have glass making technology. So glass was very hard to find in West Africa. And as soon as something stops being hard to produce, as soon as the wave is found of increasing its supply very quickly, like when glass uh flooded into West Africa, it loses its monetary role. And so this is why the world ended up on gold as money.

It wasn't a coincidence and it wasn't just because it's yellow and shiny. It's no coincidence that gold is the metal that has the lowest supply growth rate and also became money all over the world across governments intergovernments across history across thousands of years because it holds on to its value much better than the other forms of money. Now there's a fundamental misunderstanding here. MMT people keep saying money is debt, money is debt, money is debt. Now this is a very big mistake.

You can use debt as money. You can also use mugs as money. You can use microphones as money. You can use tables as money. You can also use debt as money. But historically or I mean categorically there's a fundamental difference. Debt is a liability for a money. A debt is denominated in money. Money is the thing itself in which the liability is denominated. A claim on money is not the same thing as money. A ticket to a football match is not the same thing as sitting in the seat and watching the football match.

And you don't create more seats in the stadium by issuing more tickets for the game. So this difference between the idea that money is just debt ignores the fundamental question. Okay. Well, if money is debt, what controls the ability of a person or an authority to continue to issue debt? So if money is debt, why can't I just continue to issue more and more IUS? I have $1,000 in the bank account. I'm going to keep issuing more and more IUs.

Why would people not accept? Why would people continue to accept them? Eventually I could buy everything by issuing IUS. Well, eventually there's going to come a point that my IUs are going to be devalued. people are not going to take them at face value because they're going to think there's no way this guy has all of this money. They're going to have to be devalued. So, what determines the fact that what allows these IUs to be used as money.

It's violence. It's government control. It's government violence. It's essentially a system of slavery that forces you to use these tokens and gives the government and the people who control the government and the banking um institutions, the banking cartel and banking monopolies. It gives them the ability to issue money that you are forced to use. So you're constantly having your wealth stolen from you to finance them. And of course this is presented as if it is being done in order to build the nation and in order to help society.

But really it is to help the bankers and to help the people in power. It is at the expense of the people in society. And of course this is the cause of inflation. This is the cause of the economic problems which then are used to justify more and more inflation, more and more money printing. But the question then comes back to it. How could you maintain IUS as money without force, without coercion, without putting people in jail for not using it?

Because if left to their own, people aren't stupid enough to use IUs that can be made at an infinite quantity. They always resort to holding something harder. That's why we see, you know, in always when you see high inflation, the currency collapses and people switch to a harder currency. You see it in Venezuela, they go to the dollar. We're seeing it with the dollar. The dollar is increasing in its quantity. people who are intelligent and can understand this have already switched to Bitcoin and it's benefited them.

This is a process that is always going to continue and unfortunately the role of the uh state financed economist in this is to continue to gaslight people into thinking no no no it's actually for your own good that you use money that is designed to steal from you because this is somehow socially necessary. Do your part get robbed to benefit your banking overlords. That's how we build a society. You brought up the idea of theft and I want to bring in Jason because I I want to know what you have to say.

Lots of things to say. The word Orwellian was was put on the table quite early on. This idea that economists are using language to basically gaslight us as ordinary people into accepting our fate being enslaved in a system that we have no control over. H that's a lot. But how do you respond to it?

>> There's so much to say here. Look, I mean not not all economists are the same first of [laughter] all. So So there's like there's there's orthodox mainstream neoliberal economists. We are against them, right? Then there's heterodox economists, Marxist economists, feminist economists. I mean, the idea that all economists run on some kind of conspiracy.

>> All the non-Austrian economists are in one [laughter] conspiracy,

>> some kind of conspiracy to get us all to like subject ourselves to the or the overlord paid by the central banks universities. If you're central bank, [laughter]

>> it doesn't it doesn't include us. Um but but but first of all, um I want to start with where we agree very strongly.

>> Yeah. which is that uh that clearly we we agree that this is a deeply undemocratic money system, right? Like this is my main problem with it. The money system is profoundly undemocratic and it shouldn't be because again uh as Pavina pointed out um money is a public good. It it can and should be a public good, but it's not in our current economy, right? And so in the current economy uh it's overwhelmingly controlled by the commercial banks.

Um and uh and and effectively I mean it's interesting that that that Scythe is kind of uh like keeps pointing to the state as the problem here, the government as the problem here. the government has effectively tied its hands actually and has given incredible amount of control to an independent central bank over which there's no political influence um or or very little like finance as major influence over the central bank and then of course the commercial banks that's primarily what what runs the money system right and

>> and that's because these banks then have the power to issue money to create money and put it into the into the system

>> the these are the overlords of finance you might say and and whoever and again like whoever is whoever controls finance is controlling production it's determining production uh and so the commercial banks are effectively um determining what gets produced and what doesn't get produced because they're they're making the loans uh accordingly according to what's important to them which is of course profit maximization and repayability etc etc. So things that are again not profitable are not going to get produced under this arrangement and this and this by the way explains the fact that we are failing very profoundly on in one crucial task which is uh which is to tackle climate change.

Um like this is a dramatic civilizational failure. uh our ruling classes have utterly failed us on this. Um the the the rich countries are not decarbonizing nearly fast enough to meet their obligations under the Paris agreement. Now why is that happening? Um we we have the technologies that we need, all the renewable energy technologies we need. We could easily decarbonize quite quickly actually. But there's there's a problem which is that uh finance is not flowing into green transition because it's not profitable enough.

And so uh it continues to flow into fossil fuels because fossil fuels are something like three to four times more profitable than renewables. So we produce more and more fossil fuels and inadequate quantities of renewables and as a result the world is burning around us. This is crazy and and why is this happening? Uh given the fact that uh like uh in terms of democratic support people overwhelmingly support strong climate action and renewable transition. We want this uh nobody wants to watch our world burn around us and yet it's not happening.

Why? Because the finance system is not under democratic control. And on this I very strongly agree with Scythe. The the only difference here is that um is that I would say like in order to address this problem, we don't need to abolish fiat currency and move to Bitcoin. We should talk about Bitcoin because I got problems with it. Um we can keep the existing money system but bring it under democratic control. And I believe this should actually address Scythe's main concerns here.

Uh and so that this way uh you know money becomes a a real public good. We can democratically determine how it gets invested and what gets produced with it, right? Um, and this way we're directing our collective labor and our collective resources in in socially beneficial ways rather than ways that only benefit a certain small fraction of uh of our society. And of course the economists that they pay [laughter] who are bad. I want to agree on that too.

MoneyMan's Avatar
#2

Do we agree on the fact that those those economists are bad? So there [laughter] are good economists and there are bad economists. I think everybody agrees. I wonder then you said that there was a fundamental change in the way that money is controlled and who gets to issue it and that being the source of the problem as you see it in under a capitalist society. When for you did that transition happen? When did money go from being centralized, controlled, a public good into something that is not no longer serving the public interest?

>> I mean again the main problem for me here is the production system. And [clears throat] the production system that we live under is capitalism. And capitalism is about 500 years old. Uh so again under capitalism it's it's itself a very undemocratic system where basically um you know a small faction of our society uh uh controls what gets produced. They make the decisions about what gets produced. And this is um you know this is capital. This is uh the richest 1% who own the majority of investable assets.

This is the um you know the large commercial banks and the major financial firms and the large corporations. they overwhelmingly determine what gets produced in our economy and they and they determine that production around what is most profitable to them, not what is most beneficial to us. Right? So, this is this has been a problem under capitalism for its entire existence. Um, and this is why, by the way, we're in this crazy situation where we have massive aggregate production in the world economy to the point of blowing past several planetary boundaries and driving dangerous ecological breakdown.

But at the same time, we have massive human deprivation that persists, right? uh something like two 2.2 billion people in the world live in food insecurity. This is crazy. Um uh a recent study published in Nature found that uh that 96% of the population in low in in low and middle inome countries um are deprived on decent living standards. They can't access basic things like uh refrigerators and freezers and heating and cooling systems or durable modern housing things like that, right?

basic things that we can we can produce easily. Um so there's massive human deprivation even in the even in the rich economies in uh in um in the US, Canada and and Western Europe alone uh pretty close to 100 million people live in food insecurity. I mean this is crazy. You can walk around this the city uh the streets of London and you know you're in one of the richest cities in the world and you see people just completely impoverished.

There's slums in London. You walk past them when you go to work. It's crazy. So what explains this fact that we live in this society of massive aggregate production and yet so many people live in deprivation and can't meet their basic needs. Uh we have cost of living crisis that prevent people from accessing food.

>> We're going to talk about this in a second. Talk about but the main but the main problem here is the fact that we're not producing things that people need because those things are not profitable enough and and that applies to

>> how are they not profitable if people need them. It's not profitable to produce affordable housing.

>> Profitable. It would be profitable. The reason it's not profitable is that people use their homes as savings accounts because their currency is being destroyed by the economists that are destroying.

>> If I may, if I may interject, the reason that affordable housing is not being produced is because capital does not invest in producing affordable housing because it's not profitable.

>> Completely nonsensical wants to make a profit. So if people want the homes, they would pay for them and some capital will produce them.

>> So crucially, so crucially, um, of course, in order for something to be profitable, then there has to be demand for it, right? And but there's lots of things for which there's demand but capital does not produce. So for example, if you go to any town in the USA, they desperately want to have public transit systems, right? They also want to have renewable energy. Those and and they're they're they're out there protesting ask asking for these things. Capital doesn't produce those things because they're not profitable enough to produce.

It's much more profitable for capital to invest in producing fossil fuels and SUVs than it is to invest in producing public transit systems. And over and over again, including in our in the Western press, you'll see, for example, when it comes to China, repeatedly saying, "It's crazy for China to make these investments in their highspeed rail system. That's not a profitable investment. Why are they doing it?" And China's like, "We're doing it because this is what our society needs, right?" And and why can China do that?

Because they have they have a public finance system that allows them to direct finance towards things that are necessary, even if they're not massively profitable. uh and I think that's that's a major reason that we face the kind of scarcities that we do in the capitalist world economy today. Now um in terms of the history of money under capitalism, there have been many many many changes uh and we should just focus as far as I'm concerned on the existing system which has existed since about the 1970s.

Um now inflation is a problem that scythe always wants to talk about and I think this is very important and I also agree inflation is is a major issue. uh but I don't again I don't believe that we have to abandon the existing money system entirely in order to solve the inflation problem and this is where Pavina can speak very eloquently about um about how inflation can be prevented uh even in a a fiat currency system right um the main thing here is that uh let's say we have a democratic money system where we we democratically control the state which is not the case by the way right now we don't have real democracies let's say we do uh we democratically control the state and we can determine um you know we need to increase uh funding for renewable energy and affordable housing and hospitals, let's say, and all the

potholes in London. We're just going to issue money and mobilize labor uh and production to do these things that we all agree need to be done right now. There is a risk of inflation when states start doing this kind of thing, which is that uh if if you increase the demand on your productive base, the labor and the factories and the materials, the energy and the uh ends and so on um uh beyond what the productive capacity of the economy can sustain.

This will drive inflation, right? So you have too much demand on the productive base and not enough actual productive capacity. But that can be resolved by reducing excess demand elsewhere in the economy. So for example, you could for example tax the rich. Uh taxing the rich basically reduces their purchasing power and so now uh we're producing less private jets and SUVs for them so that we can produce more hospitals and renewable energy uh capacity for society. Um so taxing the rich but also scaling down unnecessary forms of production by using a credit guidance framework.

So saying we're going to impose rules on the commercial banks now saying uh you can't make investments in fossil fuels or in fast fashion because those are actually not required to resolve our crises right now. Right? Therefore that it it means that labor and those materials are now available to be remobilized towards the things that we actually need to be producing. And so this can actually allow us to uh to have a a public money system that makes the investments that we need without causing inflation.

This is crucial.

>> Say you're writing furiously. But before bringing you in, I I do want to give [laughter] Pabina a chance to respond. There's been a lot that's been said here about how money has changed, about the idea of inflation, about the fiat system itself. So in your mind, what was there a fundamental shift in the way that money works, the way that money is issued, the way that credit even works and and and and how that creates equality, inequality, supply and demand?

Uh how do you see it?

>> I don't see that the technology is the crucial um uh difference. You know, if you think of money the way I do as um an IOU that somebody issues liability, somebody accepts it, that has been historically specific in different societies. But the way we produce and provision for ourselves fundamentally changed with the rise of a market economy and capitalism and then money becomes the object of desire. We don't have societies that produce for gold coins. We we don't have that kind of social organization.

We have societies that figure out through their social mores how who's going to be the butcher, who's going to be whether it's slavery, whether it is early democracies. That is a fundamentally different production system. The technology has existed there to account for our debts. Social debts have always existed. Fast forward, I'm going to leave the ancient world. I'm only going to put a little caveat there that even gold when we had gold standards and I would say that the vast majority of money has been non- gold.

We even had longer silver standard than gold. And I will say gold in of itself has never been valuable unless it was stamped with the seal of the king. Not all gold is created equal and the king will accept only the gold that is stamped. That is his gold. Um but again I'm going to leave ancient history fast forward to the modern day. Um where I find I agree with say that there is a coercion in the system that there are you know there are there there uh taxes that are imposed on the population on society there is as old in ancient times um and they um affect who produces who gets what who consumes right okay um how can we democratize that system I agree with you that we want to be thinking about how do we democratize that uh public nature of the of the uh of the

financial system. I find fault with the private finance, not with the public finance, with private finance. Like I said, anyone can create money. The point is to get it accepted. So yes, banks create deposits, loans create deposits, but it's not just commercial banks. Mega financial institutions create financial instruments of various sophistication. Whether we're talking about standard commercial paper to uh bonds, corporate bonds to credit default swaps to derivatives of derivatives, the financial system has its own logic of creating various financial instruments to finance finance not to finance productive capacity.

And this has been the cause of instability throughout modern society. It's it's it's not the government that is coming to rob you. it is the private sector that is that is creating all sorts of ways in which um uh you know they can get your house if you can't pay your mortgage um and it is destabilizing to the overall economy. So I think we need to look at financial crisis have always since the tulip mania have always been associated with some kind of scheme private scheme where somebody has tried to sell you a tulip bulb or something else or shares in the South Sea company right and people's you know uh savings have have disappeared so not governments government is not exactly robbing you government is very deliberately enriching certain actors in our economy so just think of procurement think of contracts you So the government has the power of

the public purse. It has financing institutions to issue currency to award contracts and then it gives no bid contracts to all sorts of predatory actors that are price setters that set very high prices and the value for money is eroded that way. So this so I agree that we need to be thinking about how is money introduced in the economy. What are we getting for it? You know what are we paying for it? You know, if a battery that is sold to the Department of Defense cost you $1,000, that clearly is not value for money, but that's not the same thing as inflation.

That is somebody choosing the price that they pay and essentially supporting certain private interests. Um, and yeah, I would I I have a lot more to say of how we can figure out a better standard. I would disagree with Bitcoin being the standard, but I think there are ways in which you can peg the currency emitted to something concrete that is of social value in the economy, labor for example.

>> And we're going to have time to talk about solutions because that's definitely why we're here. Uh but safe your thoughts.

>> Yeah, I think so. The key point here is that you guys mentioned that um essentially it's the private sector that's doing the robbing, not the government. I think it's true. It is essentially private actors. I think government is categorically just made up of individual people. It is essentially the tool that people use to rob the rest of society. So it's kind of pointless to say is it the private sector, is it the government, it's individuals and groups of people and bankers who are making money and using the politicians.

However, the discussion from the um pro- fiat money side is always very very um hesitant to bring up the reason of I agree with you. Yes, these private banks are creating all these credit obligations that are in fact increasing the money supply because when a bank issues a mortgage issues alone, it's generating new money. So yes, it is private sector that is creating the new money supply. However, it's very important to understand that if it wasn't for the central bank being a monopoly that has control of the currency that can destroy the value of the currency by increasing its supply in order to bail out those banks when they get into trouble, none of this would happen.

So the creation of money would drop to zero in a financial system where the central bank told these private banks if you ever have any liquidity problems I don't exist in or you know the in in an ideal utopian scenario where society does not have a central bank where the central bank is completely nonexistent no bank can create money if you create more money than you have assets to back that money then you are just going to be subject to a bank run and without a central bank to create new money to bail you out, then you're going to get destroyed in the bank run.

So, the market economy has a wonderful mechanism for preventing people from using debt as money, which is the people who use debt as money are going to inevitably make more debt than they have the ability to repay. That's going to devalue the money. That's going to create a bank run. That's going to destroy the usability of money. and then we'll go back to using money that has a limit on its supply because people don't want to be robbed.

So the only way that we can escape this is when the government's central bank is using the currency that everybody uses to bail out those actors. Get rid of the central bank, you get rid of that problem of the creation of money. And this here brings us to the um real fiction here is this idea that well okay the system currently is bad but that's because it's not democratized. So if we just democratize it, you know, we put magic pixie dust on it, then it becomes democratic and it can do all those amazing things, you know, whatever it is that you want.

You want to solve housing, you want to solve inequality, you want to fix the weather through u using all kinds of unproven, unprofitable technologies, all of that is possible because now we have the democratic control over money. And this just this is the eternal scam of um fiat money and fiat economics in general is to keep telling people the truly um perverse idea that the system is fine. It's just the people in charge of it right now are a problem, but if you vote for me and my buddies, then we're going to get in and we're going to fix the weather and we're going to fix everything and we're going to end homelessness.

No, the system is built on a foundation of theft. And the idea that if we just replace the current thieves with my group of thieves, then we're going to give you all of the nice things that you want for is the same scam that has been tried by this group of thieves and by every group of thieves. That's what they do. They get into power. They use inflation. They benefit themselves. But they can't get into power by saying, "Hey, I'm going to actually use inflation to benefit myself and my buddies." No, I'm going to use inflation to solve homelessness, to solve the

>> I was just saying it can be done without causing inflation. So what's the argument here?

>> Yeah. And but that's fictional. That can't be done.

>> I just explain to you how you have to argue against what I've what I've

>> But you didn't make an explanation. [clears throat] It's just well, we're just going to take money from other places and then that's going to make it happen.

>> I said we're going to reduce demand elsewhere in the economy. But you have to explain why that's not going to

>> I'm trying to explain to you why. Because all that that does is that it puts you in charge of all capital allocation in society.

>> It doesn't put me in charge. It puts the the the democratic process in charge. Right. democratic process which has always resulted in a small group of people being in charge and being able to use this to benefit themselves.

>> Sorry, we've never had a democratic

>> No, we do. This is it. This is how it works. You can't just keep saying this is not

>> I've just been trying to tell you it's not this we do not live in a democratic system right now. Deeply

>> undemocratic. You can't just continue to to um pretend that you are some representative of some utopia that we would all have if we just voted for you. We have this system. It's been working. This fiat money system has been in operation for 112 years all over the world

>> and it has always done one thing only. Destroy the value of the currency to benefit the people at the top and pay the economists who promote this idea. So the notion that you're going to come to me and tell me no. If my buddies get elected then we're going to just take all of that money and allocate it not to enrich ourselves, not to enrich and benefit us, but we're going to do it to actually fix society.

Is just another justification for theft. You know what would actually fix society? would actually fix those problems that you really care about, the poverty and the homelessness and the lack of homes. Not robbing people. It's not about finding better thieves to rob them. Not robbing them, letting them have their money, letting them have the ability to maintain the savings in their own money would allow them to solve those problems. But that's not the issue that economists solve for.

That's not the issue that the left solves for. That is about totalitarianism and control. And that is why the left has always been so strongly supported and financed by the central [laughter] banks that create the inflation because you prove you guys provide I know I know it is it sounds very shocking but really historically accurate.

>> Come in.

>> Yeah. No no listen we have had a world without central banks. We know what that world looks like. You know before we we you know figured out central banking and elastic currency we had private money and we had fiat money bills of tra of credit and various IUs that private uh banks issued to finance the devel capital development of the economy. It wasn't wasn't the government coming in and saying you do this. It was the merchants that I mean you know government supported some of these explorations but the economy became capitalist economy because private investors took initiative and they traded and they build things and those schemes didn't turn out to be profitable and they collapsed and the world without central banks was a world filled of depressions before the great depression we had depression it is absolutely true booms and b and and they documented we have to

have a sense of history depression happened after the let me just finish it happened because they went off look at all the depressions before the great depression the capitalism was filled with booms and busts and the data we we uh have collected it I mean you can't just deny the data of massive explosion in in industrial capacity and massive collapses who gets hurt it's always the little person it is always the household and society decided that we needed elastic currency to be able to prevent these deflationary spirals when assets start collapsing when values of homes collapse when wages collapse it was polity it is messy it is not I'm not justifying the current system but um we arrived at a solution where we create a public utility public money to be able to stabilize the system do we need a better system absolutely but our preublic currency was a highly

unstable system Why do um various private actors want to backs stop to the government? Because it is the only thing that can you know can can stabilize a financial crisis,

>> allow their theft to continue.

>> So you would rather have massive bankruptcies to wipe out uh households and deflationary spirals so that we can have sound currency whatever that means. This is for me exactly like saying if you're an addict to drugs and you are really really really desperate for your drug hit right now and I'm telling you you shouldn't take the drug then you're telling me oh you just want me to continue to be in withdrawal forever. No if you didn't take the drug you wouldn't be in withdrawal in the first place.

The create the reason that creates the financial crisis in the first place is the inflation. So even before the creation of the central bank, even before 1914 in the US, there were there was an enormous amount of government monopoly regulation on the banking system which allowed banks to engage in credit creation and that is what created all these booms and busts. However, these booms and busts were very short-lived. Why? Because the government was on a gold standard and as long as the uh government was on a gold standard, they didn't have the ability to just devalue everybody else's money to bail out the banks.

So the recessions or depressions if you want them they were more frequent but they were a lot less painful because they only destroyed the people who were involved with that bank. The bank itself was destroyed and the people who were involved with it were be destroyed and then that's it. Everybody learns their lesson and we move on and we have a much safer world. That is exactly what happened.

>> That's unemployment.

>> No no no that's not this is this is this is propaganda. The US from 1873 to 1914 had the fastest most steadiest growth under a deflationary system.

>> Suggesting we go back to the 1800s.

>> I certainly would believe it is an enormous improvement on our awful monetary technology. However, it is incredibly wild. I know. I know you guys. I know you're not very familiar with my perspective, but I am familiar with your perspective. That's why you say that it's wild, but I'm very familiar with yours. However, I have a very important question for you. You said society decided to move away from hard money to elastic money. I'd like you to please demonstrate to me where that choice was taken by this society of yours.

Because as somebody who's actually read history and not MMT fiction, I actually have a much different idea about how this came about. It was a bunch of bankers who realized that this is not working for us. Every time we engage in inflationary credit, there's a bank run. We get into trouble. Wouldn't it be nice if we had a central bank that could force everybody in society to bail us out every time we get into trouble because we devalue their currency because we create more money and then that constantly bails out the bank.

That's how the Federal Reserve was created. It was created in a meeting by seven private bankers in a place called Jackal Island. It passed into law on Christmas Eve when most people weren't paying attention and then it became law and it's been law for 112 years. The idea that people decided on this is nonsense because when it was introduced the mission of the Federal Reserve was to protect the currency and it's completely destroyed the value of the currency.

So if it was really the people or society or whatever these abstract nouns uh that mean nothing

>> abstract nouns I I just I just want to say uh clearly there is power and clearly powered interests uh

>> want backs stop from the government you know uh I am with you on uh getting shutting down the banks the ones that

>> No, I'm not for shutting down the banks shutting down the central bank stability. No, no, no. It is the private banks that are bringing

>> shut down the central bank and let them survive for on their own.

>> No, not at all. Use the central bank for the sorts of things that society bailing out the banks.

>> No, the society needs the kind of things that Jason is talking about. We have we have actual real problems. We have climate problems. We we have uh health issues. We have well-being issues. If you uh have a concept of well-being um then you want to think about how do we provision for it and well-being for the person is not having gold coins in their pocket. Well-being is having healthcare, having housing, having clean air that's what wellbeing is.

So we can use

>> having gold coins is you can be able to afford those things without being a slave for the government giving them to you by

>> the government. You I cannot provide healthcare for everybody and we ask institutions to provide these public goods. I mean that is you know if if you want us to go back to the stone ages that's fine but we have collective understanding of collective provisioning for collective needs.

>> So how did society decide but no I want to know how society decided to move to easy money.

>> I think I might be able to help with this. I'm a bit so okay so look I think that um

>> there's a couple things. First of all, the idea that central banks fund leftist economists

>> is completely

>> leftist economists only exist in universities. Universities are completely funded by central banks and money printing.

>> This is very obvious.

>> I'm sorry. You don't know what you're talking about.

>> No, I do know what I'm talking about. I've been at universities. [laughter] I know that all this idiotic Marxist and Keynesian nonsense continues to get promoted by the same central bank funded universities. Why? Because it says to people we need to print money because of all these stupid reasons. We fix the weather. homeless by printing money.

>> You need to give us a chance here. Sorry. Go ahead.

>> So, I think it's a little bit silly to say that every single person hired in every public university around the world.

>> I didn't say every of central bankers and aligns with their ideologies. This is just not true. Um the second thing is look to the extent that you're upset about the way that central banks operate in the sense that they bail out private banks. I very strongly agree right that's that's a major issue and it's very clear that the central bank has power to um to influence economic outcomes and it only uses that power typically under capitalism in order to prop up uh uh commercial banks uh and pump up asset values massively to the detriment of the working classes and massively to the benefit of a small elite.

Uh that that is clearly a problem. I think we can agree on that. Um the idea that's uh but here's the crucial thing. It's true that that prior to uh central banks as institutions, capitalism wasn't a crazy boom bust cycle kind of situation, right? The guilded age, which you're referring to as a as a great time, was actually terrible for most people. Uh it was a time of just mass miseration for the working classes. I mean, union organizers are being shot uh massacred in the USA.

Uh right. Where where's the

>> this is the late 19th century.

>> This is the Yeah, that's the late late 19th century. Yeah. um whereas uh whereas the uh the richest 1% were making out like kings. I mean it was it was an era of just absolutely extreme inequality. We don't want to go back to that. Now it's true that that uh that that the central bank was basically uh established um by commercial bankers. Um it's also true that the central bank can uh provide an important public good in stabilizing the economy and directing finance and important in socially beneficial ways.

it doesn't tend to play that role again because that is not the objective of a capitalist economy. The objective of a capitalist economy is to uh ensure the profits for the capitalist class and in this case also commercial banks. And so the point here is simply not that central banks as a thing need to be abolished but rather they need to be democratized and align with uh and aligned with um with uh with democratically determined objectives.

>> But you just said that and you just assume that that is true and then you said therefore the central banks don't shouldn't be abolished. Well, I'm telling you there's no way that they can play this role. This role is only theft and abolishing the central banks would be the absolute best thing that could happen to humanity. and you have haven't given me one reason why I would s I would in any way sympathize with the existence of central banks except for the fact that you just cannot fathom the idea that they don't exist and because of the fact that you continue to assume that all of the their actual track record of the last 12 years raping pillaging and destroying the planet and funding war and funding mass theft and genocide and creating an global enslavement system where the entire planet is being impoverished to enrich a few small

group of You want to treat all of that as just something that we could just ignore. Oh, it's No, no, no. You're very for those things because you support completely you support the institution that makes them because you are under an extremely delusional belief that somehow if we just vote for the right kind of thieves, we can fix this institution that has caused more evil than anything in human history and replace it with pink unicorns and flowers and fixing the weather and climate change and fixing homelessness and all of that stuff.

No, you can't. This is an institution that whose only function is to increase the money supply, which is how to rob people. You can't use that for good. Central banks don't create resources. They simply redistribute existing resources. Central banks don't produce anything valuable for society. Valuable things are labor, capital, actual real resources. Correct? Central banks don't make more of that. All they do is they move create more papers, more claims on that, allowing people to redistribute that. any attempt at redistributing that puts the person in charge of the money creation as essentially the owner of society.

You're in charge of all the capital. You can just allocate capital any way you want and we've seen how that works out and it's massively destructive and it's massively massively terrible. To go back to your question,

>> I do want to stop on this point because I want to clarify something even for myself. Pavina 1914 is the year that you uh mention as being this fundamental shift between the way that money was working before and the way was money was working after. What happens at this moment in time and and why

>> society decided apparently?

>> No, we we create the the Federal Reserve Act 1913 and uh Congress authorizes uh the creation of a central bank and this is a England had a central bank. There's a long historical process. Uh

>> and before that who was issuing money in a in a society like this? Look, there are um the US as a as a as a nation project has attempted to have a public bank since the beginning of uh its uh revolutionary war. When the colonies was established, they had to use British currency and they um you know they they rebelled against this. They wanted to manage the economic affairs. They needed to price debts. They needed to invest.

Money is is a tool. It's just a tool to facilitate activities and it is reserved and there are all of these powered interests that we want to look at but um it is essential that you have some kind of control over that particular social technology. So what ended up happening uh with uh with the British Empire um they put in place currency laws in 1751 and 64 preventing the colonies from issuing their own currency. How do you get the British currency?

You have to export all your stuff to England to be able to get the currency to pay your taxes. If this is what say is calling theft, fine. Okay. The colonies realize we shouldn't be producing our labor, our resources, shipping them to our colonial power. We should manage our own resources, build our own houses here. So, we need our own currency. We don't want to be beholden to the British currency. That was one of the reasons for the Revolutionary War, to have independence.

And look at how every colony gains its independence from its colonial power. One of the first thing that happens is they change the currency. They untether slowly. Sometimes sometimes more quickly Iraq war the first thing that happens change the currency. Why? Why does society that doesn't believe in chooses to have a new instrument to manage its own economic affairs? Because we have this modern nation state that needs X Y and Z. And I agree bailing out banks is not a proper use of that public function.

Um robbing whatever you want to call it. I you know we have ways of thinking as a society what we need. Um so it's this is just you know this is technology doesn't help you to answer these questions. It is polity and it's deliberation and it's how we organize production that helps you answer the question. It's not a matter of changing the currency from a paper to a bitcoin. In fact I think bitcoin will make it worse. It is about decision making and power making and that is just in the service of where we invest who gets employed and that's it.

money itself doesn't create labor. So, so this is the you describe it as a way for countries to exert sovereignty over their own ability to manage economic affairs and direct their public purse to uh you know what you would hope would be social useful ends

>> and this is ultimately what a fiat currency is right

>> yeah I mean fiat it's always been fiat currency you know so it makes it sound like you know gold was the always the the money of of of account but it was not it was in the history of time gold was a very small um time that it was used most of the time It was virtual. It was ledgers. It was accounting. It was bills of credit. It was paper. Fiat is just that it's not backed. There has been collateralized money by gold.

Yes, they were gold coins. But that is immaterial to the function of money and how it is being used and how it is is being created. Can I just say first of all, I do believe in a thing called society. I know that it exists. I just think that the way that um fiat uh promoters use the term is simply to just uh it's it's a euphemism for our banker bosses.

>> Well, when you say it's not my words. Yeah. I don't know. You're putting words in our mouth.

>> When you say fiat promoters, what do you mean by that exactly?

>> I mean basically, this is really the key point to go back to your question where you said, you know, it's absurd to say that all of these economists are No, I think it is not absurd. I think there's one test to determine whether you're an economist or a central bank employee. Do you think the money supply should be increased? Do you think there should be an authority that increases the money supply? If you answer yes to this question, then you're not an economist.

Because if you're an economist, you should be able to understand the basics of supply and demand. You should be able to understand that increasing the money supply just adds absolutely no functionality to money because all of the existing supply of money is enough to perform all of its functions since money's function is purchasing power which is independent of its quantity. So there's no benefit from increasing the money supply and there are only drawbacks and the benefits and the and the benefits acrew to the people who b who print the money.

So if you think the money supply needs to be increased and that we need people to be managing that money supply increase and that we need to manage it with whatever nice terms you are currently uh told to promote in your universities. You are essentially working for central banks. There's no way around.

>> But why is that an issue? Why do why do you think the central bank is a destructive force in these societies as opposed to a a body that is acting on behalf of

>> it exists to solve a problem that doesn't exist and it creates a far bigger problem and it continues to promote an a a truly criminal ideology which wants to convince people that no we are all of the problems that we cause are still better than the alternative of us not being there. No, actually the world would function very well with the hard money. We don't need the money supply to increase. We don't need to be robbed in order for our money to work.

If everybody could have a form of money that wasn't constantly being destroyed to finance war, mass murder, theft, everybody would be a lot better off. And I think it's really uh frustrating here to try and uh talk to economists or to central bankers who u promote these ideas because there is just so much terrible implications of inflation that they are completely incapable of even thinking about because inflation is always the last thing they think about because the whole thing is all about how we need to always keep increasing the money supply.

>> I'm sorry it doesn't even work this way. It doesn't even I'm I'm sorry to but it doesn't work this way. Central banker cannot increase the money supply. The central bank cannot increase the money supply. The only way the money stops the only way money supply increases is if somebody makes a loan and that creates a deposit. The central bank cannot force money on the population. They don't print money and just drop it via helicopters. It does not work this way.

Money supplies deposits in the system or cash in the hands of the public. The only other way that it could work and the central bank will facilitate is if the government gives a contract to maybe it's a construction company, maybe it is another contractor and they get a deposit. Then the central bank has no choice but to clear the check by law by law. No, it does. It can tell the bank that I'm not responsible for you and then the bank stops creating

>> even technically it doesn't work this way.

>> No, it is none of that would work without the central bank's bank stop. If the central bank wasn't out there bailing out all of those banks, when they create unbacked liabilities, when they just say, "All right, we are issuing a loan right now for a million dollars, but we only have $100,000 on reserve to meet that loan, but if more people want to withdraw than the $100,000 that we've issued, that's okay because we can just go back to the central bank." Kill the central bank, that business model dies.

Okay? And then the money supply starts being increasing.

>> Yeah. So, I'm I'm actually finding this conversation a little frustrating, I have to admit. And I think the reason is because um is because uh we need to take seriously the fact that not all economists are lines. Uh right and so this is very important because calling us central bankers or calling me at least a central banker I think is just well is is ludicrous. And so it's important to understand that like you know we have strong critiques of the way our central banks operate.

We have strong critiques of the way our monetary system operates. Many of these critiques actually deal with the fundamental problems that Scythe has raised. We also want to have a better society. We think that the existing system we have is not that. Uh we we propose methods for transforming it. Um and and what I feel is that Scythe is not actually uh acknowledging that and he's just lumping us all into his favorite enemies category which is the existing ruling class with their central bankers who want to keep the system exactly as it is.

But we're not going to advance if that's the case. Like if we had you know if we had uh I don't know Mark Carney here uh then you know we could have a good a good debate about what a central bank that's not fair. three of you against one.

>> But but no, but but this is exactly the problem is that we we clearly do we clearly do not align with that position. Uh I would have very very strong critiques to say uh uh to Mark Carney. And so I think that as long as this discussion tries to lump everybody into the same camp to be SI's favorite enemy, we're not going to advance. Um I'm trying to argue that we can actually address many of the problems that Cy is raising.

Like I share his concerns. His concerns that this is a deeply undemocratic monetary system. his concerns that it tends to prop up the interests of a very small faction of society and hurts everybody else. I I also see this and I and I want to see changes. Um but we're not going to be able to advance in that direction until we acknowledge at least the arguments that we're making. I think that's quite important. And so and this is true also for inflation.

I mean this idea that we we're somehow pro-inflation that I'm pro pro-inflation is just I mean this is actually just a crazy thing to say. Uh, and so like I'm very explicit that inflation can be a problem and there are ways and this is actually the first thing we think about and like this idea that inflation is the last thing we think about and who cares what happens or not is just completely wrong. It's just wrong. Um the reality is that this is the first thing we think about because uh because while money can be created the risk is always inflation.

That has to be that has that's the limit and that has to be the thing that we're always dealing with. Uh and and and there's very clear ways to do that. And what I've proposed already very two specific things. One is that you can use taxation to pull excess demand out of the economy and therefore prevent inflation. Or number two, you can impose a credit guidance framework on the commercial banks. Therefore, saying uh we're going to say what kinds of investments you can and cannot make if they're socially destructive or ecologically destructive, you can't make them.

And we're going to redirect commercial finance instead towards most more socially beneficial things. Right? uh scaling down less necessary forms of production like the SUVs and the fast fashion and the the military-industrial complex which by the way I'm also very strongly against Scythe um uh actually creates a non-fiscal pay for it liberates real resources which is actually what matters and I agree with Scythe here it's real resources real labor real productive capacities that matter here uh by scaling down less necessary forms of production you liberate real resources that can be redirected towards doing socially beneficial things without causing inflation this is a very powerful argument And so, and so I really want to appeal to everyone who um who aligns a scythe uh uh in believing that inflation is is is a is a big problem we want to address.

There are in fact ways to address that, but it does require more democratic control over the over the finance system, which we don't have. And this is a very important point I want to make, which is that we do not live in real democracies. This is so important. We live in effectively fake democracies where uh we get to elect our public officials from time to time. Um but when it comes to the production system and the money system then we don't get uh any real democratic say whatsoever right and this is what determines our lives like the direction of finance the direction of production the way our labor and our resources get used uh in production this affects all of our lives it shapes the direction of our civilization it shapes what we do every day and we don't have democratic say over that right so there's a real divorce

because we have democratic say in in kind of an abstract political sphere where we vote once every four years but no democratic say over the actual economy like where we do production and how finance gets invested. We don't at all. And so what I'm trying to say is that we need to extend the principle of democracy into the realm of finance and production into the realm of money system so that we can determine what we what like what do we want to achieve as as a civilization.

What are the things we want to do with our labor and our resources and our factories. Um and this can allow us to to meet our goals uh without causing inflation, without enriching the ruling class and benefiting uh humanity at large. We don't have that system right now because of the flaws that I've mentioned, but those flaws can and should be addressed. But that's a political question. It's not about like it's not a technical question of of the actual money system.

That's much less important. What's what's much more important is the politics of it.

>> Right. I think uh and and the key problem here is is is the is the capitalist nature of our economy which which strips us of power as ordinary people and the working classes and gives that power to a few unaccountable elites. That is the main problem. And and I think to everyone who's listening to Sciph and thinking um he's he's putting his finger on that, it's true. We agree. Uh but there's ways that we can address this uh through a more democratic money system.

And I think that we can actually build bridges.

>> I I think viewers can really see where I'm going to respond to this. You are using all of your critiques in order to just gain the legitimacy to then say, "No, let's not change the way that the system works. Let's just change the system.

>> I just said, sorry, I've just said we we need to change the way the system works." No. Well, specifically, well, when you say that the system works for you, it's about all these superficial details. When I say change the system works, it's about the fundamental question. And it's why no hang on. I'll let you finish.

>> Control over production is not a superficial detail. Fundamental.

>> No, no. The fundamental detail which is why you and Mark Carney are on the same team is the question. Should the money supply be increased or not? If you believe that there should be an authority,

>> I know. But [laughter] if you believe that there's a there's a there should be an authority that decides how much the money supply increases, then everything the differences between you and Mark Carney and all the rest of the people are just completely superficial and immaterial. Cuz at the end of the day, it's a committee of people that decides who gets to have how much wealth. And you're just telling us that because you're somehow good, we are just going to have to trust that when we vote you and your buddies into power, you're not going to do the same thing that every single person who has ever handled the money printed over the last 112 years has done somehow if we just vote for this next time.

You know, this is like the Charlie Brown cartoon where it's just always, no, no, just vote for me now and then finally we're going to rob you for a good cause. No. If you actually want to change the system, you would take away the ability of the people in power to rob society systematically through inflation. No, that's not what you want to do. You [laughter] just want to be the one who handles it. You want to be the one who decides who gets to

>> build who gets to have an [clears throat] SUV, who gets to have credit. I'm saying we take away the ability of anybody to create more money and then people have their own wealth and then they can decide how to spend that money. As long as you're not willing to accept that, then you're just doing central bank propaganda.

>> Chase. Yeah. I mean, look, I don't even know what to say about this. Like, I'm not running for political office here. So, I don't [laughter] know. Like, me becoming the governor of the central bank, I mean, is crazy. Um, so, but but but but I will say this, like it's true that we have not had we've not had the kind of uh system that I'm calling for in the history of capitalism because it's capitalism. I'm calling for a break for that, for a break for that.

Right. And so, and so and so simply pointing to the past and say it doesn't matter who's been in power, Republicans, Democrats, it's always been the same problems. I agree. I exactly agree with this, but this is the the problem is that they have the same interests, right? The Democratic Party and the Republican party are both pro- capitalist parties. They're pro- finance parties. They want to organize the money system in the way that it currently is organized. They differ on very very minor things.

And that's true for the the main political parties in the UK as well, right? Um but that it doesn't have to be that way. I mean, we can also have uh political parties that promote the interests of the working class uh and promote the interest of labor and promote the interests of ecology and want to organize society for the common benefit and not for the benefit of of a few. And so simply saying that we haven't had this in the past and therefore it can just never happen, I just think is not true.

I mean, we also haven't had Bitcoin in the past, but that is not to say it can't happen, right? I mean,

>> we've had it for 17 years, but we've never had your

>> I think this is a good opportunity to talk about Bitcoin. You wrote the Bitcoin standard. who are a very public advocate of Bitcoin. How do you think first of all, how does Bitcoin essentially operate and why does it solve the problems that you've put on the table?

>> Yeah. Well, the short answer to this question is that Bitcoin is the first way for an individual to opt out of the central banking slavery system that um everybody has to be part of. If you want to be part of a modern economy, you need to trade with people and you need to trade with people that are not just across the table from you. some people in the next town or in the next country. And so for that you need a banking system.

And everywhere in the world, banking is a monopoly that is organized by the government and that is organized in a way optimized for the government to continue to rob society through inflation. You can't opt out. You have to use the government's money. You have to use their bank account. You can't just set up a bank account with another currency. You can't set up a bank account with gold. This has been completely criminalized because society decided. By society, I mean, of course, bankers.

And so you have no alternative. Government won't let you set up any alternative that allows you to escape inflation. Of course, because if you had the freedom, everybody would opt out of inflation. And you know, maybe only the MMT hardcore uh believers would remain, but then they won't have much wealth. So inflation would die.

>> This is why you can't just take cash out and and stuff it in your mattress because it

>> No, because even if you take the cash out, the cash is being devalued because they're creating more and more of the money supply. So you can't just opt out. Your money is there. your bank is engaging in all kinds of financial shenanigans that might implicate you even though you just want a checking account. But Bitcoin finally allows us a way to opt out. Bitcoin is the first technology that we have for moving money outside of the state or through international borders.

So you can send a billion dollars to China right now and the Chinese and the British government wouldn't know. So this is the first and most important thing. It's a way of transferring money internationally without having to go through the uh institutions of the government. And the second and for me the more important implication is that Bitcoin is the first form of money that's designed precisely to combat inflation. It makes the theoretical debate that we were having about the increase of the money supply no longer theoretical.

Here we are now. We have a form of money whose supply cannot be increased. So the onus is on all of the people who tell us that we need to increase the money supply to explain to us why this is going to be debilitating for Bitcoin. Why is it going to stop Bitcoin from growing? It hasn't. Bitcoin has grown at about 50 60% per year over the last 15 years. The supply grows at around 1% or 2% over the last couple of years or so.

So the size of the Bitcoin economy grows far more than the size of the Bitcoin supply which again is another uh nail in the coffin of the idea that we need to increase the money supply in order to increase economic activity. Bitcoin shows you that you can just increase the purchasing power. So the value of Bitcoin goes up without the supply of Bitcoin going up. So the people who hold Bitcoin don't get robbed. So essentially,

>> and that's because no one is in control of the issuing of Bitcoin. There's no central

>> there's no central authority that can decide the supply that can increase the supply. And the supply is only created through a mining process that is open to anybody and anybody can enter it. And the cost of mining a bitcoin is roughly equal to the uh cost of a bitcoin. So nobody can make bitcoin for free. Bitcoin doesn't have a back door designed for making the people in charge of it steal you, rob you, which is essentially what government money is.

It's the whole thing is just a way for them to rob you. So, Bitcoin is your only way of opting out. And people who have chosen to opt out of this have done very very well for themselves because it's money that's not designed to rob you and when everybody else is using money that's designed to rob you. So, I think the uh you know, the good thing about Bitcoin for me is that it makes all of these debates moot.

I'm sorry to say it.

>> [laughter]

>> We can talk about

>> I mean the value of Bitcoin in terms of what?

>> It's in terms of dollars.

>> It's in terms of everything.

>> It's the value

>> that's a meaningless objection. Everything has an exchange rate with everything else. Bitcoin in value the way they would might store you know uh you know gold you know that is it is not money.

>> Gold is money. Gold became not money. It's it is not a unit of account. You don't nobody denominates their transaction in Bitcoin. They denominate them in dollars. bitcoins worth of dollars. So the the dollar whatever the state currency will remain the unit of account. Um the government doesn't tax you in bitcoins and so you are you don't have that primary reason to use that particular unit of account. You want to opt out of uh and you know I'm sure you're going to say that taxation is theft and the government is robbing us all.

It's fine. [laughter] I am trying to explain I'm trying to explain how the the system uh functions. We have never had a system where society spontaneously chose

>> a precious metal. It's never been the case when society spontaneously every single society [laughter] which is not just to read a little bit of history and a little anthropology to know how money has not been a single society that by the end of the 19th century was using gold.

>> Let's destroy the environment to mine one bitcoin. It is the annual consumption of a household per year of energy consumption. This is the world we want where we could absolutely destroy the environment to mine a very limited something that most people don't have access to. Often it's used in very shady um and illicit activities. And so yes, I can see the appeal of wanting to opt out of regulation, some kind of accountability um and the law.

>> Jason, what do you think about Bitcoin? Yeah, again I think that like I want to appeal to people uh who who are attracted to this idea because I understand why it's attractive. Um again like uh for people who feel like our existing money system is controlled by unaccountable elites. I agree I agree with that sentiment. I really feel that's true. Um I I don't think that Bitcoin is the answer. I think that Bitcoin uh look most people who promote Bitcoin uh promote it from a libertarian perspective.

And here too I think that the question of politics and power becomes very important because the libertarian view here is simply that those who have money should should have the right to do anything they want with it. Right? And I think this actually becomes a problem and this is actually one of the problems that that uh that corrupts our existing our existing money system which is that people who have lots of money are the ones who end up determining production right uh they're the ones that end up mobilizing labor and resources to do things that are beneficial to them and their profits and their consumption.

And that's one of the reasons why we face all the kind of crises that we do. I don't think that that Bitcoin as such solves that from a libertarian perspective because it's the same framework letting rich people do what they want to do hoarding money uh using it for their own uh enrichment right this is not how money should be used um right because and here again I agree with Siphon in this perspective that it's actually not money that matters it's real resources and labor so the question is what is the purpose of money here money is something that ends up mobilizing real real resources and labor that should be under the control of of a of of a democratic policy that determines how you want to mobilize resources and labor.

I don't think that simply shifting to Bitcoin actually solves that fundamental problem. In fact, if you ask me, it leaves that fundamental problem intact. And so, and this is actually is is demonstrated with the way that Bitcoin currently operates, which is that the vast majority of Bitcoin is held by a very small number of people. It's very very heavily concentrated uh among very rich people. Um and and also furthermore, they can do whatever they want with it. elicit transactions that they want.

They can uh they can invest in uh enterprises that are very profitable to them even though they exploit labor. So it's not clear to me that the way this um the way this operates is necessarily going to lead to a better society. I think the same power imbalances remain uh which is the question of who actually controls the resources. And so what I want to say is that um you know whether it's cryptocurrency or or whether it's our existing fiat money system the the really fundamental question here is do we have democratic control over what gets produced and how our labor and resources get mobilized and bitcoin does not in and of itself solve that problem.

I also think there's another crucial issue here which has to do with the global south, right? Global south countries actually really do require um a national currency in order to escape exploitation by uh imperial powers, right? This is actually really fundamental. Uh one of the core tenants of imperialism is to prevent global south countries from having real sovereign control over their currencies. So they're tied into western money systems and dependent on western finance. Bitcoin actually further reduces uh the sovereignty of global south countries because now all of a sudden you have the wealth that's maybe piled up in a particular country controlled by its millionaires right which is what how most of the bitcoin is um then gets used for whatever the millionaires want and not for the benefit of that society which needs to build an industrial base which needs to meet people's needs build hospitals build roads etc

etc bitcoin does not help us do that and so for anyone in a global south country that wants to increase economic sovereignty and achieve development and meet human needs Bitcoin actually actually undermines that ability uh because you're effectively losing uh your surplus uh uh through mil through what are effectively millionaire holdings with no accountability. And this is actually a problem.

>> So a couple of years ago uh during the COVID pandemic, a lot of people that I know, a lot of my friends started buying Bitcoin and I didn't. And now I'm at a point where I feel like if I go and buy Bitcoin, I'm at a disadvantage because my friends that bought it a few years ago are going to be so much more wealthy than I am. How do you see that problem that there are early adopters and then there are also millionaires that have come in with a lot of money.

Is this just recreating the same system of inequality?

>> No, it absolutely is not. And I think the fundamental difference in the way that this is presented demonstrates a very very serious difference in the worldview. In my worldview, the notion that somebody has more toys than me a after I turned eight or so, that stopped being a massive issue. So, the notion that I just go around comparing myself to others and they have more, I believe is an extremely toxic and destructive uh mentality. What I do care about is that some people have the legal right to create money that devalues my money whereas I do not.

That to me is a crime. Somebody having more toys than me is inevitable. there will always be people that have more toys. So I think it this is again another one of the ways in which um supposed enemies of central banking are really just promoting central banking because when they present the idea that there's a natural distribution of wealth where some people have more than others. When they present that as being equally problematic to a world in which some people had the legal right to call themselves society and rob us all by setting up these criminal enterprises, then we've just made it so that this criminal enterprise that is the central bank appears to be benign and benevolent and something that can be fixed and changed.

No, the difference is very very fundamental. Bitcoin does not have any authority that allows people to take the wealth of others. If some people end up with more Bitcoin, that's because they chose to do that. Your friends chose to buy Bitcoin in 2020. You didn't. [laughter]

>> That's your problem. That's not my problem. I chose to buy Bitcoin. I don't have that problem. And so I, you know, my advice for dealing with that problem is make sure you buy Bitcoin. If you want to continue to object to Bitcoin, if you want to continue to find ways in which it is wrong, congratulations. We've all been there. And that's just going to add several zeros to the price that you're going to pay for Bitcoin. And it's going to just essentially mean that all of your fiat wealth is going to be transformed into Bitcoin wealth at a massive discount the longer you

>> So you're saying Bitcoin is inflating in price.

>> No, it's not inflating. It's increasing in price. It's adding

>> You said it's adding a bunch. It's more expensive for us to buy Bitcoin now.

>> Yes. Because the dollar is inflating because inflation is increasing the supply, not increasing the price. So I think that um I think that uh like in the society I'm just really not clear. I I mean again I think you've actually revealed quite a lot about your about your objectives here which is that um which is that you believe that that money or Bitcoin in this case should be an object for investment in speculation and you become rich this way right and you accumulate this way.

>> No necessarily if you'll allow me to just please correct this. I I don't think of money as an investment. I just think that money shouldn't be making you poor. It's not like you buy money.

>> But I but I agree with you. I agree with you on that. The money should not make you poorer, right? Like I agree with a system that is going to rob the working class is fundamentally wrong and we have to stop that. I'm just I'm trying to get my head around the Bitcoin situation here because basically what you're what you're trying to say to me is that um is that you're encouraging us to invest now so that we become rich in the future.

Uh right now now um and you're actually okay you're fundamentally okay with very extreme inequality. uh which is also why you're okay with the guilded age of the 19th century which was an era of very extreme inequality with and very dysfunctional societies as a result. I mean a massively impoverished working class which you you tell us you're against the impoverishment of the working class and you want you want us to have a functional society. Um but but I just don't see how uh people accumulating Bitcoin is going to get us there because crucially again like we need to produce uh things that the owners of Bitcoin are not going to want to produce.

Okay. So for example, we need to be able to produce things like uh like a railway system. We need to produce things like um like agroecology. We have to produce renewable energy technologies. We have to produce affordable housing. Uh there there are many things we have to we have to care for the elderly and for children and we have to build a school system etc etc. There there are things we have to build to have a functional decent society that allows workingass people to live flourishing lives that those who hoard Bitcoin are not going to be willing to make investments in.

And here too I think that in this sense Bitcoin does not solve the fundamental problem. Oh it does. it does not solve the fundamental problem of of a society that doesn't that that lives in crisis, has very high levels of inequality and fails to meet people's basic needs. And that remains unfortunately the case.

>> So if you just simply had a form of hard money that didn't allow government to rob everybody through inflation, then government is going to be spending a lot less money on all of the criminal and stupid things that they do. They will just inevitably not be able to go and invade half the world because they can just print money. So the cost of the Iraq war was about $8 trillion. the cost of the Iran war is likely going to be in the trillions of dollars.

If you imagine the uh US government going to the American people in 2002 saying please we need to collect 8 trillion that's tens of thousands of dollars per household um so that we can go launch a war in Iraq to bring them democracy and peace and help their daughters go to school or whatever. Do you think Americans would have paid up that money in cash upfront to go and invade Iraq? No. fiat world is designed specifically for this.

Get rid of all of these silly propaganda about it being a way to help society. All of that is just banker propaganda. The main function is to finance war, theft, destruction, and that's why it can be done because there's a money printer. The money printer can always pay off that stuff. So all of the romance about fixing the homeless problem or all of that stuff doesn't matter because fundamentally it's all about that theft or war. And if you take away that theft from war, if the American people didn't have to spend that $8 trillion and the American government couldn't just take it from them through inflation, there would have been no war.

And then with those $8 trillion, you can have all of the pink ponies and unicorns that you want. This

>> I've never, just for the record, I've never called for pink ponies or unicorns [laughter] or magic dust, whatever it is. Okay, what you're saying is it's just ridiculous because we serious argument. Yeah. The point is $8 trillion spent on the Iraq war were only possible because of fiat money. Get rid of that. That means $8 trillion can go toward everything else.

>> This actually illustrates

>> because people can then decide to do it.

>> This illustrates a key point. You pointed out that that that uh if you were to do a democratic survey of the of the American people, they would not vote for the uh for the war in Iraq or the war in Iran. 100%. This illustrates my point which is that these are fundamentally undemocratic societies. We do not have democratic control over the money system

>> because of the central bank. they that overrules what the people think.

>> And in and in a situation of Bitcoin accumulation, it's also not democratic, unfortunately, because what that means is that you have a situation where you have $1, one vote, you and your buddies,

>> to use your terminology, who have lots of Bitcoin, then get more votes in what gets actually produced in the economy, which is deeply undemocratic as well. And so, no, how am I going to go and launch a war of 8 trillion against Iraq with my own money?

>> And so, in in terms of

>> the only way this thing works is through theft. The people who run this business aren't spending their own money to go fight these wars. In a Bitcoin world, it's their own money. Can they go and spend their own money? No. The whole point is

>> wars under the gold standard.

>> Yes. And they were a lot less and they were a lot less

>> technology is not going to change power.

>> The wars were a lot shorter and they would get resolved quicker and they were nowhere near as destructive as the wars of the 20th century. Yes.

>> Wars. Yes. The Napoleonic wars killed a lot fewer people than the World War. Yes. No, no, no, no. There's a very serious difference that we had two world wars under fiat money. You can't just brush this off. Why did we have the world war start exactly when we went off fiat money? Before that, under the gold standard, governments fought until they ran out of

>> mini wars. We want just tiny little wars. Like it doesn't

>> under the gold standard. Governments fought until they ran out of gold. Under fiat money, they fight until the money in the hands of all their people runs out of value. That's a lot more runway. That's why World War I could last for 5 years. That's why it continued for another 30 years and then we materialized in World War II and that's why war continues and that's why the ask continues to do it. So really if we simply just simply take away the ability of government to finance itself with inflation that would massively reduce war.

And I think it is incredibly telling that the people who claim to oppose the war then claim to want to do all of these other different things with the ability to steal wealth through inflation don't point that out and continue to say no no no we need this. Okay fine. It's caused hundreds of millions of death and it's robbed billions of people and it's impoverished billions of people. But one day with democratic oversight, one day we're going to use it for the force of good.

Well, no. Let's take away this machine that actually creates all that death and destruction and then see how society works out then.

>> Excellent. I just want to bring in Pavina first. I mean, what do you make of this idea that the mere concept that governments or central banks have the power to create money, inject more money into a system? I mean not not and I know you said that they don't actually create money in that way but that then incentivizes these governments to embark on very expensive pursuits like wars without having to worry about running out of money.

>> Look, I'm not defending wars or governments bailing out banks. We I have written about this uh explicitly opposed this. Um my focus has always been on the real economy and there is a confusion. It's not money that finances the war. It's people. It is the resources. It's who's fighting the wars. It is who's producing. It is the, you know, base, the material base that actually instead of producing things that we all need. Um, we are developing bombs.

That is the issue. To me the question of technology is not the specific technology but it's a question of um of uh monetary design like institutional design and it's a it's a question of of uh governance of law. It is a question of law. It is not a question of the specific thing that is being that is being used. Um I have no illusion that wars are going to stop because there's Bitcoin. I expect that far more exploitation is going to happen if that very scarce resource is is somehow the only thing we use to pay for things.

I find I expect far more uh deflation uh defaults. The way the economy works we we can't just start from some hypothetical I consider this scenario to be the unicorn scenario like we have to start from here to there. Like we need to figure out how from this system we get to a more democratic system. And um the bitcoin is priced in in in dollars. It is priced in uh already existing currencies. You don't uh simply just disappear the the current monetary system.

And even if you have uh bitcoin as a standard, you will not uh prevent the speculators issuing liabilities denominated in bitcoin. Right? that the problem is that there will always be somebody issuing some kind of loan and it's not the government you know like the government can abuse the monetary system. I agree 100%. But the instability that comes within this market system this mode of production comes from somebody making a loan that doesn't pan out that goes that bankrupts and as a result it bankrupts you know it reduces the asset of a home of somebody reduces somebody's wages cost them a job.

So we need to think of how credit is created, what it is created for, what it finances, not what it's denominated in. That is my my basic point. I am all for democratizing the current laws and the way governments banning forever wars. Let's ban forever wars. Let's p pass a law and you know stop stop right. I mean but that's a political question. It's not a question of monetary design.

>> No, it is not a political question because let me ask you a hypothetical question. If you're saying that it doesn't matter what the thing is that is underlying the money, then [snorts] it shouldn't matter if we use Venezuelan dollars and US dollars, right? What's the difference between Venezuelan dollars and US dollars? They're the same, right? It doesn't matter. It's just about credit and I use. No, there is a big difference. The Venezuelan dollar is increasing in supply at around 100% every year.

The dollar increases in supply at 8% per year. So, if you built the system on the Venezuelan dollar, it's going to be very different. Why is the dollar a lot the US dollar much better? Because it increases at a much lower supply. If you can accept that, which I think anybody should be able to accept, an 8% inflation rate is better than an 800% or 100% inflation rate supply increase rate, then it also necessarily follows that a 0.8% in increase in the supply is going to be different.

And I would say is going to be a lot better because it's not just about laws. We can't just pass a law and say war, make it illegal or something. The people that are in charge of the money printer are above the law. Everything is sub everything is under the money printer. Everything can be overruled by printing money. It doesn't matter what laws you pass. The people who are in charge of the money printer, if they want their war, they're going to get their war.

It doesn't matter if they want those things. As long as the mechanism exists for them to rob everybody, rob billions of people around the world with the dollar. It doesn't matter what you write in laws. It doesn't matter who you vote for. None of that stuff matters. They have the ability to do it. And then you can keep crying about it for decades. Like we've been crying about the Iraq war for 20 years now. Doesn't matter. Doesn't change anything.

They get to take the loot and then they leave people to argue about it. Bitcoin takes away from them the ability to loot you. That's why it matters. That's why it's something very important. And here I think there's a very um important question here. You said deflation. You said that like it's a bad thing. Please explain to me why it is a bad thing if prices of things drop. And please explain to me why that has not destroyed the tech industry.

Phones are cheaper every year than the previous year. Laptops are cheaper every year than the previous year. Every year your memory, your uh processing power is a lot cheaper and yet the high-tech industry continues to grow into trillions and trillions of dollars every year. So why is it that this idea that prices go down is a bad why why are prices declining a bad thing? And wouldn't you, so, you know, so you've been talking about democracy and helping people and housing and all of these uh wonderful ideas.

Wouldn't that help with the cost of living crisis if people started paying lower prices for things? Wouldn't it be nice if every time you went to the supermarket things got cheaper rather than more expensive? Why is it such a terrible idea? Please explain.

>> It's a terrible idea because all contracts in a market economy are nominal. And when you lock into your mortgage and it cost you a million dollars over inflated, you know, home value and uh there is a massive housing failure, then the value of your home goes down to $100,000. You're still liable to pay a nominal contract for a million dollar. You cannot sell your asset. You default. And that's what defaults are. And that's what happened in the late 1800s.

All contracts are nominal. They're not in real terms. And falling wages, falling asset prices are devastating to a money. We are in a money economy and contracts are in money terms. And so uh you uh that is the deflationary power and we found a way around this. You want your wages to go up. You want your assets to go up a little bit. So you know because you live in in nominal contracts, you do want to have a little bit of [clears throat] increase in

>> value. I don't I absolutely do not. And in fact, the reason that there are these crises and there are these crashes and housing is because of the inflation that happened in the first place. So the inflation is the root cause of these bubbles and these crises. But the but you're specifically mentioning deflation in the context of monetary collapse. And the reason is as you said earlier, it's true economy.

>> Exactly. When banks issue loans, they're creating new money. So when you default on your loans, some of the money supply has been destroyed.

>> So that sounds like we're doing something bad because we're destroying money.

>> Cost jobs. It costs your ass. That is what matters. Hang on. No, no, but I'm saying this is only a consequence of the fact that the money supply is inflationary and expansionary. Only because the bank can increase the credit lending by generating fake money out of nowhere is it then does it then become systematic when the uh home borrower defaults. But I'm saying put that aside. I'm saying in an economy where we're just having the money supply is fixed and the production of other goods is increasing.

So the price of other goods continues to decline.

>> You can't have money supply fixed and the production to be increasing. For production to increase in a monetary economy has somebody has to extend credit. So the money supply increases by the increase in the production. There are many ways in which the money supply can increase that are um uh speculative. But if production is increasing, somebody's financing in a capitalist economy that production therefore money supply is increasing.

>> Why can't the financing come from existing capital? In other words,

>> money is not a pot of gold. Money is not about money is created in the act of credit creation. Money financing money is created in the act of credit financing system. No, no, no, no. Fiat central banking is a system of debt slavery. That's what you mean.

>> You can get rid of fiat system and you still are going to have to have credit to finance production and investment.

>> Here's the question that I've asked you and you've avoided answering. If we don't have a central bank, people are going to create credit and they're going to issue credit

>> and they will fail

>> and they will fail.

>> That's right. And we had that system. We know what where that ends. What happens?

>> Yeah, we have crises, mass unemployment, default, and somebody buys up the assets of the person who's lost their assets. Massive wealth concentration. You got to look at the real consequences of these, which is what happened after 2008, right? With the financial 2008. Absolutely. And during the guilded age,

>> this is hilarious. They continue to bring me examples from inflation as a reason for why we need inflation.

>> 2008 was because of inflation. We did not have central banks.

>> Yes. Well, under the guilded age in the period first of all notice then there were the when the crisis would happen they were very brief and they were very short and they ended and what happened there was steady economic growth. The problem is you people look back at the 19th century and compare it against today's technology.

>> You were comparing you're giving us those examples.

>> Yes, there was a lot more poverty in the 19th century because the vast majority of people didn't have the technologies that we have today. But you don't you you need to be able to hypothetically separate the impact of the new technology causing living standards to improve versus the impact of installing a system of global debt slavery that has been robbing people. And so essentially the fundamental idea of central banking propaganda has been to take credit for the advantages that industrialization and modern fuels and modern technology have given us and somehow attribute them to central banks and then blame everything bad that existed before modern industrialization because you know all of human history is basically poverty compared to today because we didn't have electricity and energy and all those amazing things.

So then somehow all of that was because of the lack of central banking and then we invented central banking.

>> Not say any of those things. Absolutely.

>> A lot of a lot of the reason no this is what you were saying earlier that the problems of the 19th century is because we are going back to the 19th century. Yeah. We don't want to go back to 19th century technology. We want to go back to 19th century monetary policy which is a lot better than what we have right now without inflation. Can I can I just say without inflation, without the ability for somebody to create the money supply, any bank that issues $1 of liabilities more than it has assets is liable to fall in a bank run.

Once that happens, that bank goes out of business. However, in that world, it's not a systematic thing. If you're in that bank, you lost money and that serves you right for dealing with a bank that is doing something nasty. So then in that kind of world, we'd actually not get crisis because everybody would learn to be responsible. Everybody would realize if you put your money in a bank that's engaging in something nasty, you may lose your money. So people are going to be very careful and people are going to request clear audits from their banks and the banks are going to be very very very careful.

But again, that doesn't answer the question. You can still have all kinds of credit creation without needing to create new money. The existing capital is in society. It's not in the form of papers of money. The existing capital is in the force is in the form of goods and labor and real estate and all those things. We have a fixed pot at this exact moment right now. We have a fixed amount of capital. The central bank doubles the money supply.

It didn't double the capital stock that we have. It's just doubled the money supply which is going to cause all kinds of distortions about how we allocate that capital. Credit can be created without increasing the money supply. this would be healthy and would stop these crisis that you blame on the uh hard money.

>> Okay, let's bring in Jason now.

>> Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean there's several things I'd like to address here, but I'll very briefly touch on the question of prices. Um, look, there's actually all sorts of technologies we can use, very simple policies we can use to control prices. We actually do want to make sure that the price of of housing is affordable to people. We want to make sure that uh the price of groceries is affordable to people, etc., etc. Um, you know, public transit should be affordable to people, etc., etc.

So look um one way to do that is through public provisioning systems. Public provisioning systems are actually a way to ensure that prices remain affordable to people. Uh we can even use price controls uh for certain kinds of goods and services that we don't want to see inflation on. Right? And this way we ensure affordability for people. This can actually be very crucial uh for ensuring a good society. Now, but I'm actually less much less interested in that in the question of war because I I really do want to address this question because I very strongly agree with Cy that um I'm I mean I'm I'm on the record being very strongly against the kinds of wars that the US and its allies are currently engaging in the rest of the world.

I'm very strongly anti-imperialist in this sense. Um I strongly want to see global south liberation from uh this arrangement. Uh but the very cru crucial thing to understand is that this is uh is not um is not an automatic effect of having a fiat money system. This is actually very important to understand. It's it's an effect of our capitalist world economy. Uh capitalism has been around for 500 years. Um it is the in the core states, Western Europe and the USA and the the the the settler colonial offshoots.

These states have always relied on a very substantial net appropriation of labor and resources from the global south. Right? This is the this is their their primary accumulation model for the c for capitalism in these core states. Now in order to to um to enable that they invaded the rest of the world uh conducting genocide on several continents over the past 500 years um uh preventing sovereignty in the global south and organizing production in global south regions around servicing capital accumulation in the core.

This is the cause of war. This is the primary cause of war. And and and to say that wars started in 1914 is I mean a complete a complete uh denial of hundreds of years of colonial war that were conducted in the name of capital accumulation explicitly in the name of capital accumulation by the capitalist class desperate to find cheap labor for their plantations and their mines um and their sweat shops uh to enrich themselves. Right? So this is clearly happening before fiat money.

It's it's an effect not of fiat money itself but rather of the logic of capital. Um because again the logic of capital is to maintain is is to maximize and accumulate profits. To do that you need cheap inputs. You need cheap labor and you need cheap na uh nature right resources. And they get that from the global south on a massive scale. The war in Iraq, the war the war against Iran, the the uh the the perpetual attack on Palestinian sovereignty is all organized around the same objective particularly in West Asia because they understand that sovereignty in West Asia is deeply antithetical to the interests of capitalism in the West.

deeply antithetical because imagine a west Asia that controls its own resources that sells its oil and it other resources in in its own currencies outside the US dollar uh controls their trade routes for themselves. I mean imagine this is fundamentally antithetical to the profits of western firms which rely very heavily on controlling well I first of all on the denomination of oil and US dollars but also on cheap labor and uh and resources in West Asia and the rest of the world.

So any state that pursues some kind of economic sovereignty is a threat to uh the interest of capital accumulation in the core. And that's why they go to war. That's why they went to war against Iraq. That's why they they're going to war against Iran. That's why they won a wararmonger against China. That's why they destroyed uh Vietnam with firebombing. Uh that's why they did coups against the president of Ghana and the president of Indonesia and the president of Guatemala in the 20th century over and over again.

This is the kind of violence that we see. uh and it's it's driven by the logic of capital accumulation and so I strongly believe that that is what has to be addressed and simply shifting from fiat to bitcoin is not going to fundamentally uh solve this problem um because again prior to prior to fiat wars existed colonial wars existed and that will continue as long as this is the the logic of our economic system let's have a conversation then about the US dollar because fundamentally we talked about the gold

>> before move on can I just uh address this very briefly I'll say this is a very common theme that People blame capitalism for the problems of fiat money. And it is extremely powerful meme because it gives the people in power exactly what they want to hear, which is no, no, no, no. The problem is not this entire global mechanism for enslaving and robbing 8 billion people that allows us to have money that can allow us to launch trillions of dollars of war.

No, the problem is capitalism. Unless let's listen to some idiotic nonsense written by a 19th century illiterate called Karl Marx and that will somehow help us explain how the world actually works. No, the problem is not capitalism. Capitalism is not a bad word. Capitalism just means

>> you might be the first person to describe Marx as illiterate. By the way,

>> he was semi literate to be fair. But the problem is not capitalism. Capitalism is just the natural order of human society. As a species, as humans, we developed the ability to we developed the cognitive ability to build tools and to develop property and to take care of it. That's it. The first human being who ever made a tool to hunt a rabbit was the first capitalist. And the first guy who tried to take that from him and tell him, "No, no, no.

You can't hunt a rabbit with it." That's the first anti- capitalist. It's just simply a justification for theft. If you have a problem with capitalism, essentially what it sounds like is I have a problem with people being able to own things and do with them what they want. That's what capitalism means. The problems of capitalism that we whether we are taught to attribute to capitalism are the consequences of fiat money inflation. And of course, this is why, in my opinion, you find that all the leftist authorities, all the leftist intellectuals, all the leftist professors, they're always railing against capitalism.

They have no idea whatsoever about inflation and how inflation works. And they're getting paid by central banks or central banks who pay universities. It's such a coincidence. They are somehow incapable of understanding this very, very, very, very important point. It's not a conspiracy. It's very obvious. I've been to universities. I see people in universities take this Marxist garbage seriously all over the world. 200 years after this garbage was written, people still take it seriously in the same universities that are financed by the central banks.

What explains that? Why can't they just stop this if it was

>> those Austrian economists and universities? Most of the economists are neoliberal economists and they all said

>> neoliberal economists are just statist economists. The again the difference is do you believe that the money supply needs to be increased? That puts all of the Chicago people, all of the Keynesians, all of the Marxists, all of the heterdocs, all of the MMT, you all believe in inflation. And you just fight about who gets to be the one.

>> I'm sorry. Sorry. Sorry. We can't have a conversation. You keep saying that we want inflation. We We said you want this government to be in charge. You want people to use it.

>> But I really think the weather and do all of those things. You want people in charge of the money.

>> I I just want to bring Pabina in just one second because you keep saying we want to change the weather. I mean, again, you're using climate deniialist conspiracy theories. I'm not saying that. I'm saying we should have more renewable energy. This is widely understood. But let me leave that aside for now. Um it it doesn't help if you continue to tell us that we believe in inflation and we're stooges of the central bank. We've made it very clear that's not the case.

Can we please have an arguments about what we're actually arguing? This could be more helpful I think.

>> Yeah. So so so maybe uh we'll we'll we'll leave the insults against KL Marx specifically and maybe other people as well. [laughter]

>> But but Pavina um a question for you then about the idea of increasing money and about sovereignty which you brought up earlier and you brought up as well with to global sovereignty as well. the ability for countries to issue their own currencies to control their own currencies. Can this happen while at the same time they don't have the power to increase the amount of money that that is in circulation? Is there a way to create a fiat system without also increasing money?

>> I am not so sure that I understand the question. The money is created when we finance economic activity. Um and so uh you can have money that is privately created. You can have Bitcoin and money will be created. You you can you can have the Bitcoin standard and if somebody makes a loan in Bitcoin that will create a deposit and then somebody else is going to deposit in another bank and they will be credit creation and money will be created and it will be denominated in something else.

Okay. Uh for me the question is if we have this technology um this public utility I want to be very clear on record that it has to be for the public purpose. I am absolutely once again absolutely against bailing out banks. Um I find that the process of credit creation this links to what Jason is saying that in a in a capitalist economy it is the object is more money at the end of the process. That is the process.

So you start with some Bitcoin assets, you want to end up with more Bitcoin assets, right? The logic, that logic is not disrupted. You want to have more money at the end of the process. And that process creates a lot of private finance, a lot of entrepreneurial, financial innovation, all sorts of schemes that are destabilizing to real production, real employment. That creates a financialized system. Layer on layer on layer of financial assets denominating whatever you want to denominate them.

Okay, that is the financialization of capitalism to me that is the problem. I would like to rein in you know these various forms of credit creation um and the the state whatever you may think of the state and I'm not here to defend the state um but you know we have created rules of the game laws and those are flawed and we've marched on and we've looked for better rules and now we're talking about can we move past the rules of this particular logic in this system.

So if we have this public utility, the fiat currency, whatever it is, can that be deployed in a non-inflationary way and this is very much part of my own research. How do you anchor the value of the currency something that we as a society value? Um I have proposed that we whenever we emit is issue currency that that is linked to a specific production of social useful labor something that we all value um employment care environmental work etc.

Not speculation not wars. So to me these are the value questions. The questions are how we organize society. It's not just this, you know, easy shortorthhand that the government is robbing you and that we live in slavery. We all understand the injustices in this world. We all understand the public sector doesn't function as well as we want it. But we also want to find tools that will enable us to be more self-sufficient and independent. And I think this is where you know Jason has a really important point.

You want uh the global south to to delink to decouple from the dominance of the dollar or west or colonial currencies to still dominate you know northern Africa CFA Frank for example to be able to invest domestically uh in its own resources but we are told constantly and this is also very very funny that it goes completely against the inflationary um narrative. We're constantly told that the government doesn't have money. We we're constantly told we don't have the money to pay for employment, for infrastructure, for housing, health care and that is that idea is weaponized to in fact not only tie the public p for those ideas but enable the public p for war mongering.

So once again for me these are the questions society is grappling with. They are far less questions of uh of a unit of account. Kane's uh whatever you may think of is work talked about a bank or a unit of account that will um denominate international transactions right we don't have that system today we can envision various ways of accounting for our transactions um so that you know surpluses don't accumulate in one country deficits don't accumulate but the questions are about the real the the the real trade real employment real um productive um logic of the system
>> Jason let's talk about the global south. You you brought up the idea that um there is this vast inequality between how different countries are able to operate within a global economic system. Can you think of an example where the kind of democracy that you see or that you believe can be exerted onto a monetary system, an existing monetary system, is there a kind of society that is able to practice that in our current world?

>> Yeah, it's interesting. So um look there's no like perfect example out there that one can point to but there are certainly places where certain policy tools have been experimented with very successfully. I think that um I think that China is actually a very interesting place. Now what's interesting about China is that I mean if you just if you read the western press on China then again like I was mentioning the highspeed rail investments earlier they they think these kinds of things are crazy like China's going to have an economic collapse because it it's it's deflating its housing bubble.

China's going to have an economic collapse because it invests in public transit systems. These are not profitable etc. And all this just gets gets proven wrong. Now so and and and what's interesting also is that China is making very very rapid um uh gains in renewable energy uh capacity. It's leading the world in this very very easily uh by a long ways and um and this is this is a bit strange to observers because you know why is the west unable to invest in these important future technologies uh to an adequate degree whereas China is you know is very successful at this um and the reason is simply because China is able to mobilize um finance and investments around socially necessary things that are in alignment with its uh with its national development objectives um without worrying about profit maximization as the core principle.

This is so this is very important. And so I recently in fact spoke to a um an investment banker in China and he said look um what's interesting about China is that uh is that is that profit is isn't even on like our top three or four or five list of priorities when it comes to the investments that we make. Our our our investments are supposed to be in line with what is decided uh in terms of national development objectives.

Um and this is why they're able to make investments in say reforestation which is a very nonprofitable sector. You don't get profits from re from reforesting land, right? Um and in poverty alleviation, in highspeed rail development, in renewable energy. These are lowprofit investments, but they're socially beneficial. And I think that's uh that's um that this illustrates the power of one crucial policy uh principle which is called industrial policy. Um industrial policy um is when there's an alignment of the productive forces with achieving uh set development objectives of some kind, not just profit maximization.

And a crucial piece of industrial policy is credit guidance. This is something I've been calling for earlier and I think can address many of the concerns that Cy has rightly raised actually. Um credit guidance is when we can impose rules on commercial banks and guide their investments towards things that are beneficial to the working classes, beneficial to our society rather than just beneficial to elites. Um so having a public finance system which is what which which China does have having industrial policy having credit guidance all of this can help to uh reorganize our considerable productive capacities towards things that are more beneficial for ourselves and our in our future.

Now um uh what's important is that this should be democratically determined as much as possible. And here again I agree with Cy is that is that we want to make sure that that democracy is the core of this. People have a real democratic say in the way that these these uh these frameworks get implemented. Um and and so I think that's the horizon really to to find ways to use industrial policy and credit guidance and public finance um in ways that align production investment with democratically determined uh objectives.

In this way our labor and our resources are being used for our benefit. This is the crucial horizon.

>> Safe. What do you think? Um so first of all I would say um I I I agree on the idea that this notion that well we don't have money for healthcare, we don't have money for those things is used essentially as a uh as an excuse because you know there's always war for another there's always money for another war but there's never money for the homeless. And I think it's ridiculous. And I think um I think the China example makes a good counterpoint to this that no actually if you don't spend 8 trillion more money $8 trillion dollars on Iraq uh you can just spend them in the US and actually that might not be the that that would be better.

And I think you know here I disagree with some of the more libertarian aspects on this that there's the kind of very strong opposition to this notion that no if the government is interfering in spending then things must go badly. I think China illustrates a good counterpoint and that there isn't a high degree of government coordination. I think what matters more is inflation and for me the the the the fundamental reality is that China is essentially a lot less inflationary has lower taxes than the US.

So even though you know and I agree with you on the on on the ridiculous propaganda against China, China's been on the verge of collapse for the past 25 years. Ever since I've basically started reading about the world, China's only 15 minutes from collapsing implosion. And you know, I we've seen Shanghai go from a very poor city to the world's biggest metropolis, and somehow we're supposed to believe that it can all fall apart in 15 minutes. But I think the case for China, I think it's not as strong of a uh support for industrial policy in as much as it is a u first of all not wasting our money on wars and b not having high taxes, not having high inflation and also having property rights.

I think that the real thing that drives the Chinese miracle is the fact that over the past 45 years, China went from a place where there were no property rights and now they have property rights. And this is an enormous enormous enormous difference. And I think um this you know the implication here is that as we move away from um central control toward more property rights we get a lot more prosperity, production, freedom and happiness in China. And I think um you know historically yes there's you can always point out to the examples of successful industrial policy but I think there are a lot more examples of failed industrial policy.

And when you count the cost through the inflation, then I would say there are probably a good case to be made that in many of these countries, they would have probably done better if they had not spent so much resources on industrial policy. So there's an enormous amount of cost to these things and the cost generally just gets ignored. But yes, I agree. It would be better to spend money on industrial policy than spending it on war. And the the you know you can wish that you end up being ruled by people who are enlightened who don't spend it on war and spend it on things that are better or you can just take away from them the ability to rob you to finance it.

This is really why Bitcoin is such a powerful uh solution because it just allows people who are productive, who have wealth, to opt out of being robbed and therefore they're able to uh continue to allocate their capital towards the thing that they see important and that just makes it extremely expensive and difficult for governments to continue to rob people in order to finance these terrible things.

>> Let me jump in here. I we are throwing around this inflation word in such a cavalier way. You know, if you ask today's family, do you care that the price of chewing gum in the 1930s was 10 cents? Nobody will care. That that is not what matters to people. But some nominal, you know, value of of a of a good has is bigger. Uh wages are bigger, wealth is bigger. We don't have diseases, we have more housing, we have general well-being.

That's what matters at the end of the day. Today, the problem of inflation, the one that really bites, you know, that really hurts people in the pockets, doesn't come from overprinting. It has nothing to do with overspending. And I I'm not even using the word over printing because that's not how it works on a technical matter. It's not overspending. It it comes from largely supply shocks, energy shocks. We can literally track where the source of inflation is, where the choke point is, how energy feeds into the production of other commodities.

Like you have to look very closely at these mechanism mechanisms to understand that anti-inflationary policy is not an money policy. Bitcoin is not going to help you with the straight of hormuse. It's not going to help you with energy and oil shocks or oil embargos. is not going to solve what is essentially a real problem. China, perfectly good example, has various schemes to stabilize prices of their essential commodities. They have buffer stocks. They hoard, they accumulate reserves, sell them on the market when prices go up and then they relieve those price pressures.

And when you know prices are lower, they buy up they they replenish their um their reserves. So there have been since ancient Egypt buffer stock schemes to stabilize the prices of what are essential commodities. What matters to the household is what they eat, right? What it cost them to feed the family. And so Egypt going back to ancient history, you know, it didn't even have specific thing that was money. It was all virtual. They were just rec recordings on the ledger.

But they thought of the real ways in which they can stabilize the prices of these essential commodities. We have other ways of doing you know Jason suggested a few other ones but that's what matters to the economy to deal with inflation is um largely on the supply side how to alleviate those shocks and only in wartime economy we have seen demand pull inflation where indeed governments have spent so much on the war effort and all the production capacity was directed towards production for war that it took a while for the civilian economy to readjust and start producing refrigerators rather than tanks.

These are the questions. They are the questions of how productive capacity is directed to fight inflation. They are not just of some printing or some fiat money that robs everybody in their pockets.

>> No, I think it uh I'm going to take the counterpoint. No, it actually absolutely is about the fiat money that is robbing everybody from their pocket. Why? Because we can just look at the supply. We have extremely reliable data on the supply of the money and we have extremely reliable data on the prices of commodities. And there's a very very serious change that happened in the pricing and the supply after 1971. Money supply started increasing a lot more rapidly.

Prices started increasing a lot more rapidly. Let's just take one example. Oil. Before 1971, I think the price of oil had always been between$1 and $2 or something in that range $2 to $3 something like that. 1971 happens everything, you know, a lot of the inflationist propaganda tries to pretend that it was because of the war in 1973 and the Arab embargo forward oil.

>> Complete nonsense. Complete nonsense.

>> And the reason is the oil embargo first of all didn't really affect the world markets all that much. It was nowhere near as effective as this uh Iranian uh

>> so the lines in the US were fake fake news. All the lines of people lining up

>> the lines were caused by the price controls and the quantity controls that were imposed by the government. If you look at the quantity of oil that was imported in the US during that period, it barely moved. What actually happened? And then of course the embargo ended and the price didn't go down to $3. In fact, it's just kept going up which shows that it's going up with the increase in the money supply. It does. It's at 12 stabilize.

It went up now because of the oil shock again. It's oiling money. It never went back to $2, which was the price in 71. Why? Because the money supply kept going up. The money supply kept increasing. So that that devalued the money. The price of gold went parabolic after 1971. The price of oil, the price of copper, every single thing increased in price drastically from 1971. And it's today several multiples of its price in 1971. That's not a coincidence and it's not because of supply shocks.

All of these things got more expensive because the money got cheaper and that coincided with the growth in government spending on wars. that coincided with all kinds of social problems, all kinds of problems in society come from this. And this is really I think where um you know the world would benefit a lot from taking inflation a lot more seriously because it's no coincidence that all these economic problems and I you know you gave the example of chewing gum and I find that just absolutely astonishing that um so many economists like to trivialize inflation by saying well 100 years ago chewing gum was 5 cents now it's five who cares.

No, actually there are more important things than chewing gum in life. One of the most important thing, shelter, houses. Today the average American worker needs to work for something like 10 years in order to afford a house of the cost of a house. This is actually something astonishing. This is the destruction of human civilization because all of human civilization we're trying to provide the basics on the mass low hierarchy needs food and shelter. And all of human civilization is us developing new technologies and new ways of making shelter more and more affordable so that it becomes easier for us to make it.

And indeed that's what's been happening. If you look at the data for thousands of years the cost of houses in terms of labor has been going down. And then that reverses around 1914 because we shift to an inflationary currency. And then that reverses even more after the 1970s and 80s because then we shift to a really inflationary currency. And what that means is that people can't use their money as a form of saving. And of course, this is something that most economists don't see as a problem because saving is presented as if it is a terrible thing.

But when people can't use money as saving, what are they going to do? They're going to use their house as saving. So the result of this is that now a lot of people are buying second and third homes. Why do they do that? They don't want to be real estate investors, but they have to be because if they keep their money in cash, it loses 8 10% per year. If they keep it in a bank, they get 0.5 or one or two or 3% or whatever.

It doesn't beat inflation. So, they have to go out there and buy a house and they have then rent out that house. So, what have they done? They've priced out the young people. When you're a 25-year-old fresh graduate, you're getting married. Do you want to start a family and you want to buy a house? You're not just out there competing with other other 25 year olds looking to buy houses. You're competing with 55 year olds looking to retire.

You're competing with 65 year olds putting all of their life savings into a house. That's why you can't afford to buy the house. That's why you rent. So yeah, actually inflation does have serious consequences, a lot more important than the price of chewing gum. And I think if you ask the average family, would you like it if all of these rich people that are out bidding you for your house? If they could have an actual bank account that was not designed to rob them and then they wouldn't have to buy all of those houses and then the price of your house would be affordable.

Yes, that is how you solve the housing problem. But of course, that is a solution that you won't find fiat economists advocating because it's a solution that involves ending the ability of the central bank to destroy the currency and rob everybody.

>> I want to talk about something else and zoom out a little bit. Um, you mentioned the 1970s and there was something else that was happening during that time too which was the United States was officially moving on from the gold standard. Exactly.

>> And at the same time because partly because of the oil.

>> You should have mentioned that. Yes, that's what I meant. 1971 is when they moved off the gold standard. That's why the money supply increased and the prices of everything went up

>> and and at the same time because of the increase in the price of oil and the oil embargo suddenly there another shift starts happening which is the United States starts expecting people to only trade oil in the US dollar and then all of a sudden we start moving from gold to another standard which is essentially the US dollar and now you have countries around the world that are even pegging their own currencies to the dollar as a form of stability.

And I wonder Jason what do you make of that? What do you make of the dominance of the dollar and what it has done to either create stability or instability in the global economy?

>> Oh, this this is such an important topic. I feel first I want to deal with the question of inflation in the 1970s. While while I appreciate the arguments that are around, I think that is missing a fundamental point which is that the 1970s uh was was effectively the height of the anti-colonial movement. Right? So most of the global south is deolonized in the middle of the 20th century. What do they start doing upon independence is they start regaining control over their national productive capacities.

And so instead of producing things to export to London for the enrichment of bankers in London and capitals in London, they're producing things for local human need and developments, right? They're building hospitals and uh etc etc. Now what this means is that they're using their own resources and labor for their own development. And that means that their resources and labor are no longer cheaply available uh to service capital accumulation in the core. This actually does create a very dramatic uh supply c uh supply um side increase uh price increase for um for the for the western states which makes it very difficult for them to maintain profitability during this period.

Now one of the reasons that we um that we saw the neoliberal backlash against the global south in the late 1970s and 1980s with the imposition of IMF and World Bank structural investment programs across most of the global south was specifically in order to crush prices again in the global south. right now. When the global south's export prices become higher, this is good for the global south. This is good for the global south. It means that they're getting more for their exports.

Um it's bad for capitalists in the west because it cuts into their profit margins. And so there was um a concerted effort to try to destroy the developmentalist governments the and the nationalist governments in the global south um and uh and destroy their industrial policy which is what structural investment did and prevent them from using deficit spending as well in order to uh to constrain the ability of global south uh societies to use their own resources for their own development and then therefore production be reorganized around sweat shops and plantations uh and and so on for uh for foreign capital which is exactly what happened.

And that actually brought the price of labor and resources in the global south down during the 1980s. Visav crucially visav the price of imports from the core. Uh right. And so um and so we have to understand again uh the 1970s in the context of the capitalist world economy. Um it was liberation for the global south which was then uh uh there was a backlash against that from the core in the form of structural adjustment. Um but to go to the question of um sorry the question you just asked

>> this is about the dollar. Yeah. Yeah, this is a crucial one, right? So, um

>> uh so uh so with the the the rise of the petro dollar, we have a situation where basically the US has an incredible privilege where it's able to basically like because uh because because uh oil is denominated in US dollars. Everyone's got to buy oil. They're buying US dollars. Uh um uh there's an incredible demand for US dollars as a result. What this means is that the US has a very strong currency and as a result can effectively print money and buy imports from the rest of the world effectively for free, right?

Uh and so the rest of the world gets drained to support consumption in in the US, uh this is a very devastating arrangement. Um and uh and as long as uh as long as oil is denominated in US dollars and as long as trade is conducted in US dollars primarily and it's one of the major reserve currencies then um then basically it gives this incredible imperial privilege to the US. The same is true actually for for the European states.

As long as euros are also a major core currency, they also get this imperial privilege. Um and so it's in the interest of global south states to move away from dependence on the core currencies, the euro and the US dollar and conduct more of their trade in national currencies. Um this is this is called dd dollararization. It's something that's um that a lot of global south uh countries are talking about now as a way of reducing their dependence on the dollar.

One of the problems with with being very dependent on the core currencies is that you're very vulnerable to sanctions. This is a crucial one. So if your government in the global south does anything that the west dislikes for any reason, right, they can sanction you, cut you off from international finance, cut you off from the um from Swift for for payment transactions and uh and strangle your economy, right? And they do this regularly. So these are unilateral sanctions.

They're illegal under international law. A massive amount of global south countries are subjected to them right now. There was just a study published in the landscape global health that found that unilateral uh sanctions imposed by the US and and Europe uh over the past 50 years have caused uh 38 million deaths in the global south. Right? So this is like very severe problem. Um and so uh I argue that it's very strongly in the interests of global south countries to reduce their dependence on uh on on the dollar for trade and transactions.

Um, and I think that moving towards the ddollarization of of oil in particular is a strong move in that in that direction. And this is, by the way, one of the reasons why the US hates Iran because Iran wants the ability to be able to sell its oil outside of the US dollar, which the US very strongly rejects because that's the core of its imperial privilege.

>> And that's also about the we talked about opting out of the system. You know, what sanctions does is essentially kicks somebody out of the global uh economy and their ability to be able to trade in their uh their goods and services. Pavina, what do you think these smaller countries, smaller economies can do to be able to protect themselves against being that vulnerable to the global system?

>> Yeah, I mean the essentials of course um you can use the domestic monetary system, the uh you know sovereign currency to employ your unemployed resources and invest in essentials. Food security would be first. you know there are I mean all sorts of power structures that affect that too you know whether you're buying se seed from Monsanto and then you have to buy another contract so there are um these are the real constraints there are ways of opting out you know developing sustainable agriculture domestically I think that uh countries have a lot of capacity what is constraining them is the necessity to earn a dollar to pay the dollar denominated debt or to accumulate the reserves against which you have protect your own currency.

So then you have to ship out your food to earn a currency you don't really need or you want to have a sound stable domestic currency but you actually you know shipping out your real resources that provide for food sovereignty. So food sovereignty would be first. Um energy sovereignty will be another and you know maybe moving away to sustainable um sources of energy creation will be another way of opting out of this dollar system. It's it's it's not enough.

Um obviously if you want to have industrial policy and you want to import capital there are other power structures that are going to affect you because there will be property rights and you might not be able to access that technology and the seller might be asking you for dollars right but you can as a first approximation raise the floor you know by employing strengthening your education system strengthening your health system and these are the things that people value anyway.

So we are starting from the bottom up. we're building the kind of um you know uh preconditions for well-being um that are then preconditions for development because you know if I was an entrepreneur and I was a business person I will not go to a community that has mass impoverishment and hunger and poor health care right and so you really kind of tip the paradigm of bottomup growth by using your domestic monetary system to employ your domestic unemployed resources to provide for the very basic essentials first and you build from there.

This question of sovereignty is really key especially in the world that we exist in right now and I wonder safe what you think if you had to not on an individual level of convincing someone to buy a bitcoin for example but on a societal level what do you think what how would you redesign a country's economic policy for example?

>> Yeah that's a great question. I'd say the simple answer would be is the simple answer is that Bitcoin just completely changes the game of public finance because before Bitcoin was created, if you were a government in the third world or the global south or any government outside of the um US and EU essentially, you have the obligation you you have no choice but to use these national currencies because you want to trade with the rest of the world.

So if you're a Kenya, you know, you want to buy things from Brazil and China, the Brazilian and Chinese suppliers have no use for their Kenyan shillings. So they're not going to accept Kenyan shillings because they can't use them to pay their workers. They can't use them to meet all of their balances. So you need to give the Chinese and the Brazilians something that they want and you don't have their currency because you have no reason to hold their currency when you only buy it, use it for this one particular supplier.

You want to hold your cash balance in the money that you use most commonly. So this is really we're we're recreating the problem of the problem that money solves which is the problem of coincidence of once. And so the solution is that you're going to have to try something that you can use that both of you have it and that ends up being the dollar. Now generally I agree with your analysis. I slight disagreement on the importance of the petrol dollar to the to the function of the dollar.

In my opinion, I don't think the pricing of oil and dollars is what gives the dollar its status. And I don't think, you know, selling oil for dollar is that consequential. I think what matters are two things. First of all, the global payment networks and banking networks are run by the US government and the Federal Reserve and all central banks are look are locked into that. And so basically if you have to go through dollars or currencies backed by the dollars and then there's just so much network effect locked in there that everything ends up being priced and traded internationally for dollars.

Well not everything but the majority of things. So that includes oil but also eggplants and tomatoes and everything. And the other thing I think is what's really important is the fact that the US treasuries market the US government's public debt market is likely the largest most liquid single uh market in the world. And that means that the large holders of large cash balances, say, think of the Norwegian sovereign wealth fund for instance, if they want to liquidate their uh if they want to liquidate their cash because they want to buy Apple stock, they want to have their cash in the thing that allows them to buy say $5 billion of Apple stock with the least slippage.

So they want to liquidate their hard asset easily. So the best thing to hold ideally you know you want to hold the money but because money is devaluing you hold the second next best thing which is government bonds issued by the US government because they pay you a yield so that offsets some of the devaluation. So because of this you end up with the system where the maj vast majority of the world is locked into the dollar system.

But uh with the conclusion, I agree with you. This is just a system that is expropriating wealth from everywhere in the world to the US government just like every single central bank is expropriating the wealth of its citizens to its own benefit. Um but I also think the um the idea that this explains the 1970s, the deolonization explains the inflation of the 1970s I think is a is very mistaken. And I think, you know, I I've tweeted this before and I say it the I define a fiat economist as somebody who will believe absolutely anything can cause prices to rise except an increase in the money supply.

So you can point out to the increase in the money supply. You can point out to the increase in prices. You can show that we've never had examples in history of prices being of prices rising sustainably for a long period without a corresponding increase in the money supply. And yet every single time we get an increase in the prices, we get all of these explanations. And in my favorite, I had a whole thread on Twitter about this a couple of years ago.

Remember in 2020 when they printed a lot of money for uh COVID and everybody said there's not going to be inflation. And then of course there was an enormous amount of inflation and there was just an incredible amount of propaganda about all kinds of things to blame for inflation. There was the weather, um Beyonce concerts, um workers being too greedy asking for higher wages. There's always all these explanations except for the increase in the money supply. No, I think it was the increase in the money supply.

I don't think it's a coincidence that just when we go off the gold standard and the money supply starts increasing massively, the price of everything goes up. I don't think it's a coincidence, but the and and and the implication here is that I think you you mentioned something along the lines of the rise in the prices was good for the developing countries. The rise of real prices would be good for developing countries.

>> I said the rise of their export prices and and their wages, by the way, also good for people. Well, rise it nominally. That's the big difference.

>> No, no, I mean I mean in real terms like like they were actually like during this period their wages were increasing. They had more command over the global over the global products. They were able to consume more of what they produced and more of what the rest of the world produces available for accumulation in the core states and was a result of better wages in the global south. That's a good thing.

>> No, I [laughter] think I I think a lot of that is masked by the fact that the money was being devalued. So it looks like wages are going up. It looks like uh prices are going up. It looks like their commodities are more profitable, but in reality,

>> no, their actual real consumption was going up. Their actual real I have a sinking feeling that we're not going to solve the issue of inflation [laughter] today,

>> but we could be here for days and talk and talk a lot about a lot of

>> Can I get back to your question on sovereignty because it's related to this? Well, let me actually ask you as our final question uh because we do need to wrap up unfortunately, but there are so much that I have seen you guys agree on over the course of the last couple of hours of conversation. But as a final com comment and you know you can talk about sovereignty, but very briefly uh Pavina, could you tell us when you were younger, what is one thing that you wish you knew about money?

[laughter]

>> This is where the financial advice for me comes in. No, I don't think I thought much about about money. Getting a job. That was it. That was the one thing I cared about. I think that is the one thing most people care about. Whether they can get employment, whether it could be good employment, whether you can have a home and a family. It is, you know, I it wasn't about uh uh you know, coins in my pocket.

And so, you know, that just goes back to my fundamental point, you know, as it's about how we organize the productive capacity to provide for society. Um, and our economies are growing, they're growing in an unsustainable way. They can be developing in a sustainable way. The population will be growing. We will need to provision for for society. And it is helpful to have elastic currency. And this is not you know me advocating for particular you know state capture but a recognition that throughout time societies whatever monetary instrument that they have created has been elastic in some sense to be able to record these economic transactions that are happening and underlaying the economy.

And certain forms of monetary instruments are more unstable than others. um and they cause more devastation, more unemployment, uh more bankruptcies and so then we move on and we try to find a better monetary system to be able to stabilize the well-being of families. So, you know, I wasn't thinking about that when I was very young, [laughter] but I think ultimately that's what it boils down to. It boils down to whether I can self-determine, whether I have the resources to provide for my family, and whether some basic well-being has been um you know, I'm able to provide for myself and I live in a society that is also, you know, taking care of of those who cannot provide for themselves.

>> Jason, briefly, what would you say to your younger self about the nature of money?

>> It's a really interesting question. I mean I think that um that for most people money is kind of this mysterious thing and it's uh yeah it's it seems difficult to understand and I think that for a lot of my even up until you know I I started in my PhD I mean I was I was mystified by money and and it seemed like I mean there's all these intense theoretical debates about it. How can I ever wrap my head around the the meaning and the nature of money?

I actually think that all of that can be swept aside. I think that all that really matters in an economy is real is real labor, real resources, real production, the real goods and services that all of us need. uh right like that's what we're doing with our lives every day is we're doing labor to produce things, right? Um and so uh to understand the economy, it's actually better just to take money out of the equation and see like who's who's producing what and who's controlling the production, who's determining what gets produced for what for whose benefit, um who's who's not getting things produced for them, who's left out, who's deprived, etc., etc.

And then and bring money back in as as an understanding that money is one of the ways that uh that production gets directed, right? Gets determined. Uh and then we have to understand like who you know it's a political it's a political artifact who controls money who controls it issuance what purposes do they use it for whose benefits does it serve etc that's the key question but um but it all really comes down to how is it affecting the real economy how is it affecting real labor jobs resources that's the key um because that's actually what matters in the economy and money is is an abstraction in the sense that it's not what really matters what really matters is the real economy and money should be a tool that we can use to achieve the goals that we need to in the real economy.

That's the key. Uh and so people should not get overly obsessed with uh trying to understand the mystifications of money and the different theories of money. I think that's a dead end. Um and it makes much more sense to think about the economy in real terms that we all actually experience it in.

>> And safe again briefly apart from investing in Bitcoin much earlier. What would your advice to your younger self be?

>> I say ignore these fine people's advice to not be obsessed about money. You should be obsessed about understanding money. it is the most important thing to understand in the world right now. I think the notion that oh it just doesn't matter to focus on the real economy is an extremely dangerous idea because I would say I would put it this way. We spend all of our life thinking about how to make money but we don't realize that keeping that money is much more important than making it.

You know if it's like you're trying to collect water in a bucket doesn't matter how hard you work if your bucket is leaking. And if the buckettologists in your life are telling you not to pay attention to the leaking bucket and focus on just working harder, then you may want to consider the hypothesis that they may be benefiting from your bucket leaking. I think it's really important to understand why inflation is so destructive and I think it's incredible how little attention is paid to the topic in academia and I think that that is the one thing that I wish I understood earlier because since I understood it I um it it's really helped me so much because it's not it stops money from being this theoretical issue which you argue about academically and it becomes very relevant to your life and it matters but I'd really like the chance to

just finish the answer to the question on uh sovereignty. I I wish we had time honestly but we have to wrap things up but I

>> also inflation is bad. I'm also against it. I think

ConnorF's Avatar
#3

What an absolute master class debate by that bitcoin guy.

Personal Learning

My Learning Dashboard

Current Lesson

Reach the end of this lesson to unlock completion.
Learning Notes Current Page
Saved on this device 0 characters
Notes are saved separately for each lesson or page. General Notes are also available. Everything is stored locally in this browser.
Bookmarks Saved for Later
0
0 saved resources
Save this page so you can return to it from your Learning Dashboard.
Your Saved Material Dashboard + Knowledge Navigator
Knowledge Navigator bookmarks appear here too. Pages saved directly from the Dashboard are also stored locally in this browser.
Unit 1 Monetary Education
0%
Continue Learning Continue Lesson
Curriculum Progress Progress updates automatically
○ Not Started ◐ In Progress ✓ Complete
Opening a lesson marks it In Progress. Reaching the end unlocks completion. Only you can mark a lesson Complete.
Theme: Emerald Ledger